The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in New York City

Matt Hargrave: Amazing Sicilian style slices!

Ariez Dustoor: Sicilian pepperoni is awesome. The regular pie isn't anything special.

Gab Novick: Get the pepperoni Sicilian slice. Ah-ma-zing

Jamie Lonie: This place has an old school diner vibe with draft Budweiser and solid pizza. Plus there's awesome rap music always playing. Try a slice of Sicilian.

Christopher L: Get the Sicilian pie, crusty and pillowy soft!

Frank Rimalovski: Sicilian was amazing! Light, crispy and delicious. Neapolitan was so-so.

Sergio Ponce de Leon: Must try the namesake slice, which uses a creamy artichoke-spinach sauce instead of tomato, but the Margherita and Sicilian are also very good. Have them cut in half so that they're easier to eat.

J.H.: The sicilian is the absolute best here... How do they make that amazing crust??

From The World Blog: The artichoke one, is incredible with creamy filling. The Sicilian and Margherita pizzas are also great.

Adam F: Best place to grab a quick regular or sicilian slice... or 5. This is the best pizza in New York in my opinion. Oh, and did I mention it's open late?

Michelle Higa Fox: Joe's sicilian slice is the best in the city.

Erik Rowley: Spider-Man worked here, sling on in for the best late night New York pizza slices. The Sicilian is my fav, perfect for on-the-go just be sure to bring cash.

Winnie: Delicious pizza. Open late. Love the Sicilian and the mushroom pizza. Goes very well with bottled drinks available there. There is also an ATM there

Joey J: Can't go wrong with Joe's. The Pizza is fresh and crispy. Their Sicilian slice is one of my favorites. You can't fake a good tomato sauce. Any Italian will agree, the sauce makes the slice.

Chad Horner: a New York classic - check out the celeb photos on the walls. mozzarella and Sicilian are my favorites here.

Rodrigo Teixeira: Best NYC pizza ever! Have a Sicilian slice. It's really delicious!

Reeya Shah: Amazing slices, very convenient to penn station, penn plaza, and MSG. Loved the sausage sicilian

Kasey Ma: Um. The upside-down slice is the bomb. I've never had a Sicilian like that before. Sauce was sweet AND savory. Unheard of. I just died and went to heaven. I would starve all day to eat 4 slices here.

7th.List: They have a 300sqft wine bar serving homemade bechamel lasagna, Sicilian tapas including beef tartare w/ olive oil-infused artichokes on crostini or arancini w/ a ragu center. Read more.

Elio Artese: Great tiny, Italian (Sicilian) restaurant in the heart of SoHo. Waiters are nice and food is great. Make sure you try cannoli!

Vito Giallo: Ok this is really the best Sicilian (but the real Sicilian) food i have ever had outside of Italy. A must try

Matteo P.: A real hidden gem! Authentic Sicilian food, with an intriguing menu and a great service

David Reichsfeld: Great pasta at a fantastic price to quality ratio for NYC. Flavorful plates and great unique Sicilian pasta plates.

Jasmine D: Amazing & authentic pizza and pear salad

Rock Raines: Joe’s cheese slice is my NYC go-to. Their Sicilian square is no joke too

Martin Jonasson: A classic. Go for a slice of the Sicilian.

David Solimano: Excellent sicilian slice, crisp and not too heavy.

Naunihal Singh: Service is slow, even when the place is empty. Took 45 minutes between when we walked in and when we got our Sicilian pie, another table arrived later and got theirs earlier. Order slices instead.

Brad Williams: Sicilian was so good the first time, I'm going to try the vodka sicilian.

Brian Sell: Artichoke Slice is overrated but still good. Sicilian is underrated. Great stuff

Michael G.: Eggplant Sicilian slice

Gabriel Agostini: Recommend the sicilian style pizzas, they are the best. Pepperoni sicilian and vodka sicilian are the best

Jason Su: Sicilian spicy pepperoni is awesome.

Kimberly Vanderpol: Tony is the best!!! Grab a slice of Sicilian !!

Marsha Fischer: Sicilian pizza and an original slice! The best!

Tim Vetter: A slice of grandma's Sicilian and a little bottle of cheap Pinot Noir taken on the patio on a warm night provides the best 8 dollars of peoplewatching you will get anywhere in the city

Reagan Barbosa: New pizza spot in the neighborhood and it’s amazing. The thick, square slice of Sicilian style pepperoni was incredible. The best pizza place we have this area now.

Michael Coetzee: Hmmm. Might be difficult to distinguish the difference between this Sicilian pepperoni and the one from Prince Street 😏

KD McNulty: The sausage Sicilian was quite tasty

Terrence Aybar: Check up front to see if there are any sicilians available. They aren't just good, they're the BEST.

Sandro Maldonado: Sicilian pizzas are the best!

Luis Lopez: The best beef pattie w cheese with cocoa bread on the side. This place is truly old school with friendly staff who've been consistent through the years.

Danielle Whited: Been meaning stop here for a while & am so glad I stopped in. Friendly waitstaff & delicious Sicilian food! Definitely try the pistachio ice cream cake, it’s amazing, & the pizza Norma was delicious!

Edward Delfino: Excellent service & decor.Typical Italian dishes & pizzas, as well as Sicilian dishes that you won’t find elsewhere. They are probably most known for their arancini (rice balls), and rightly so.

Michael Cabot: Porketta cabucci which is a sicilian sandwich made out of pizza dough was pretty good. The other folks liked their pizza.