Shake Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

1. Shake Shack

9.1
Madison Square Park (Madison Ave & E 23rd St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · NoMad · 1236 tips and reviews

Drew L.Drew Lesicko: Get the Portabella burger! Its surrounded with cheese and deep fried.

Jonathan R.Jonathan Rivera: Order a Double Stack burger with a cheese stuffed portabello on top, and wipe the gooey cheese from your cheek as you enter culinary nirvana! Then go for a quadruple bypass!

Ben K.Ben K.: First time? Eat the Double Shack Burger. Been here before? The Shack Stack with cheese stuffed portobello on top of a burger is a must. Want to die? Finish it off with a Shack Attack Concrete.

Elephant & Castle is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

2. Elephant & Castle

8.2
68 Greenwich Ave (btw 11th St & Perry), New York, NY
Breakfast Spot · West Village · 111 tips and reviews

Janice G.Janice G: I love the Smoked Mozzerella & Roasted Portobello Mushroom, Tomato, Arugola and Basil Mayo Sandwich. My friends love the sauteed shrip and bacon sandwich, and the hamburgers. Read more.

Jonathan W.Jonathan Wegener: Get the portobello mushroom sandwich. So good!

Isabel Z.Isabel Zapata: A little gem in the heart of the Village. Tried the blue cheese salad and portobello sandwich, will come back for burgers and omelettes! 🍔

Sotto 13 is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

3. Sotto 13

8.7
140 W 13th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 118 tips and reviews

Sandra B.Sandra Baez: Amazing brunch! Ordered a bunch of tapas and couldn't think of anything I didn't like. Favorites were the lasagna al forno, French toast, and portobello pizza.

James G.James G.: The portobello pizza & fresh cut rigatoni w/ spicy lamb sausage and grilled octopus are really delicious. I will be back for more.

Sam K.Sam Krasnik: The Portobello pizza is great

Springbone is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

4. Springbone

8.1
90 W 3rd St (Sullivan St), New York, NY
Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 36 tips and reviews

scott ..scott ...: Great paleo options including zucchini spaghetti with meatballs and "The Port," a grass-fed beef patty sandwiched between two massive portobello mushrooms.

Karan S.Karan Sagar: Get the grass fed burger with a portobello patty, the avocado toast, or the butter bone broth with turmeric!

LexiLexi: Great breakfast — eggs, Avo mash and bacon

Shake Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

5. Shake Shack

8.5
152 E 86th St (btwn Lexington & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Upper East Side · 377 tips and reviews

Elizabeth B.Elizabeth Brim: I am always thankful when my burger-eating companions suggest Shake Shack. The veggie burger is unreal -- think juicy, perfectly crisped portabello shroom hugged with melty, tangy cheese.

Jess B.Jess B: Try the Shake Stack, but be careful as the cheese stuffed portobello mushroom is hot!

Carly H.Carly Heitlinger: The portobello mushroom burger is amazing! Don't walk out without getting a shake!

Spring Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

6. Spring Café

8.4
153 Centre St (btw Walker & Canal), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Downtown Manhattan · 8 tips and reviews

Sara M.Sara Marcos: Portabello burger is SO good!! Really cool place. Will come back again!

Megan L.Megan Luff: All vegan menu! Unassuming little spot. Great burgers and buns!

Christian C.Christian Colasuonno: The Hawaiian Chicken Sandwich was amazing!

sweetgreen is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

7. sweetgreen

8.6
311 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 74th St & W 75th St), New York, NY
Salad Restaurant · Upper West Side · 38 tips and reviews

Go Find AliceGo Find Alice: Love the pesto portobello!!

NicoleNicole: Great seasonal changes. Love the Earth Bowl. Get the app to order ahead for pickup. Easy to see all the options, customize a salad, and skip the line.

Noah G.Noah Glass: Long waits. Order ahead at order.sweetgreen.com to #SkipTheLine and experience #waitlessness

Burrito Box is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

8. Burrito Box

8.2
885 9th Ave (btwn W 57th St & W 58th St), New York, NY
Burrito Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 127 tips and reviews

Ketan J.Ketan J: Many vegetarian burritos - spinach and portobello, brown rice, whole wheat wrap is a current favorite.

Kenji E.Kenji Eu: Delicious burritos for decent prices. Had the tofu portobello, yum!

Bonnie O.Bonnie O: Great vegan and vegetarian options. Delicious tortilla chips. Try the seitan burrito with tofu sour cream and soy cheese. Mmm.

P.S. Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

9. P.S. Kitchen

8.8
246 W 48th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Theater District · 33 tips and reviews

Mark C.Mark Crozer: Ordered the P.S. breakfast. Delicious and just the right size. Perfect scrambled tofu, smoked maple portobello mushrooms and a superb sweet tomato jam. Highly recommended even if you’re not vegan.

Mary C.Mary Carroll: Burgers are delicious, cocktails fabulous. Staff really friendly and helpful. Great vibe, enjoy everyone!

Varun P.Varun Prasad: Great vegan food

Zutto Japanese American Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

10. Zutto Japanese American Pub

8.1
77 Hudson St (Harrison St and Worth St.), New York, NY
Noodle Restaurant · Tribeca · 145 tips and reviews

Sydney R.Sydney Robinson: Great Yuzu Margarita, portobello bun & fresh ingredients!

Jeanne L.Jeanne Ladd: Vegetarians! It's all about the buffalo cauliflower, portobello sticky bun, papaya salad (without dried shrimp) and shisito peppers of course!

Jason F.Jason F: Koshihikari Echigo Beer. Any bun. Tonkatsu ramen. Solid!

Tony Dragon's Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

11. Tony Dragon's Grille

8.7
62nd St And Madison Ave (Upper East Side), New York, NY
Food Truck · 33 tips and reviews

DorouliniDoroulini: I had a sandwich with portobellos, mozzarella, tomatoes, arugula & it was fantastic! We also had burger & hot dog! They were delicious! The hot dog is small. Try the spicy sauce! Good value for money

BettyBetty: Paleo eaters: Pork skewer for $4. The nuggets are bigger than quarters + 6 pc each. Totally worth it! Juicy, well seasoned, lemony flavor bomb. I am plotting how to make my way back already.

Raja H.Raja H: The charcoal-grilled meat is the highlight of Tony's cart. Sausage or chicken over fluffy rice...or both!

Wolfnights is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

12. Wolfnights

8.1
99 Rivington St (Ludlow), New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Lower East Side · 132 tips and reviews

Anya S.Anya Sarang: the portobello wrap was superb 👌🏼

Dan G.Dan Gerbarg: Silly decor, funny theme, GREAT food. Healthy with high quality ingredients, and I was happy to get a portabello wrap that shares a name with a lesser known Jim Carrey classic...once bitten.

Bastian B.Bastian Beyer: The Teen Wolf tastes great. Add a beet salad

Bonsignour is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

13. Bonsignour

8.4
35 Jane St (Hudson), New York, NY
Coffee Shop · West Village · 63 tips and reviews

Marc K.Marc Krohn: The Portobello Chicken Panini on Ciabatta was excellent!!

Sarah R.Sarah Robson: Great iced coffee and pastries are very fresh in the morning!

Quinton M.Quinton Ma: Stay away from the blond one. I love her. Also...I love the hot sandwiches.

sweetgreen is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

14. sweetgreen

9.1
226 Bleecker St, New York, NY
Salad Restaurant · West Village · 40 tips and reviews

Michelle W.Michelle Wiles: The grain bowls are big enough for two meals. Pesto portobello is my fave

Aditi L.Aditi Luthra: Anything with goat cheese ❤️

Tom M.Tom M.: Really good! Rad Thai salad , organic arugula, organic mesclun , sprouts, carrots, basil, citrus shrimp, spicy cashew dressing--- triple yummy!

Bluestone Lane Collective Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Portobello Mushrooms in New York City.

15. Bluestone Lane Collective Cafe

8.5
55 Greenwich Ave (at Perry St), New York, NY
Café · West Village · 204 tips and reviews

Ben M.Ben Mackey: It feels like home! Amazing flat whites, and the food is excellent. Portobello Mushrooms and Corn Fritters are great choices but next time I'll get the Avo Smash with poached egg and prosciutto.

Angela W.Angela Wen: Friendly service, awesome coffee, delicious healthy food. I love the portobello mushroom w walnut pesto!

steensteen: Really busy on weekends but great coffee