The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in New York City

Mauricio Prieto: Fantastic pepperoni pizza

Lina Trifon: The pepperoni pizza is great.

Connie Xiao: A fresh-out-the-oven square slice of pepperoni pizza at Prince Street = the pizza of my dreams 🤤🍕❤️

Darleny Lopez: I loved this one. The pepperoni pizza is to die for 😍 best pizza in town

Mel Helama: Capres pizza and pepperoni pizza rock!

Kristin Wyman: Pepperoni pizza is to die for 😋

Andy Ellwood: Try the Pepperoni Pizza - Celebrating a very successful #MovingDay with the best slice in #NYC

Heladamadrina: The best pepperoni pizza in whole NYC !!!!!! ❤️

Iro Prodromou: Best pepperoni pizza in New York City!!!

Griffith Kundahl: Get a Six Point beer and pepperoni pizza. Genius!

Efrain Vasquez: Pepperoni pizza and margarita are the best pizza's on the menu. Recommended but a bit pricey.

Shiyana Bellamy: I liked their pepperoni pizza. Their clam pizza was overrated, was super chewy and lacked flavor.

Kimberly Barry: Delicious pepperoni pizza! I was so happy eating it, viewing photos of famous New Yorkers there, I left my phone!! Kind customers returned it to staff. I was able to retrieve it! I❤️NY and Joe’s.

David Solimano: Excellent sicilian slice, crisp and not too heavy.

Salvador: One of the best slices you can get in Manhattan.

Sinan Arkonac: Best pepperoni pizza in the city

Nabil Bazzari: Woooow....amaaaazing pizza... yummy pepperoni pizza + get the meatballs with tomato sauce. Must try if in NY

Irene Leon: Best american pizza, that we've tried, and cool place

James Sims: Damn good pepperoni pizza!

Jason: Coal fired pepperoni pizza, salad, ravioli, and a cold beer.

Emily Bennett: Great for splitting! Their 17" pizza was enough for 4 people to have 2 slices each! Fried eggplant and zucchini appetizer was delicious.

Doc Pop: Try the peperoni pizza - My date took me here. It's her fave. Not bad.

Sinan Arkonac: Great pepperoni pizza

Nia Soria: Chicken franchaise, tortellini and pizza are the best

Samiha Khan: The pepperoni pizza is out of this world. Not sure how they get those small yet thick pieces of pepperoni to curl and crisp up like that, but it's so so good. Would come back here.

Jen Hong: Best meatball pepperoni pizza in the city!

Craig Middleton: Quaint little pizza spot with big flavors. Definitely stop in for lunch.

Chris Osgood: The little pepperoni pizza is da bomb!

Bibi Miller: Slices are awesome & eclectic. They do cracker thin crust, and it's Amazing.

David Greenberger: The place lives up to its name. 1 of the top 3 slices I've had in NYC. No need to get fancy, the plain and mini pepperoni slices are out of this world.

Meghan Farrell: Best pizza in TriBeCa, hands down. Order the Pepperoni Pizza and add fresh arugula on top

Randolph Kahle: Relaxed. Good. Very good food. Chianti was nice match to our dishes.

Porfirio Pina: Service and great food

Joanna Flamm: Be prepared for thin crust. On a date? Share one large pepperoni pizza and a kale and manchego salad and you're good to go.

Kaitlin: Excellent thin crust pizza with very fresh ingredients and inventive topping combinations. Happy hour special - free pizza with purchase of a pitcher of beer!

Chris: Try pizza.

Melinda Christie: The pizza bianca is the best white pizza I've had! Fantastic cheese and pepperoni pizza too!

Sinan Arkonac: Great pepperoni pizza but not as good as bleeker st

Kelly Weaver: Pizza of course....and the garlic rolls were killer as well.

Tabitha Berry: Pepperoni pizza was great. Garlic knots were everything.

Tabitha Berry: Awesome pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. My new must have when I come to NYC.

Joanne Bouillon: The fresh eggplant pizza hits the spot. My second fave behind Gaby's.

Rico Paborito: Yummy Pepperoni pizza!

Laryssa Richards: The gnocchi were amazing as well as the penne with vodka sauce.

rob l: chicken slice is the best. additional seating upstairs for more private dining.