2. Motorino
8.4
349 E 12th St (at 1st Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 318 tips and reviews
Camilla C: Margherita is amazing here... Might be my favorite manhattan pizza.
Darrin Chung: I had the Margherita and the Soppressata Piccante pizzas, and both were amazing. the crust is perfect and they taste great. Prepare to wait if you go past 7 pm though.
The Daily Meal: In addition to the traditional varieties of marinara and Margherita pizza, Motorino offers a handful of more spirited pies, including one with cherry stone clams, and another with Brussels sprouts. Read more.
4. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
8.1
321 E 14th St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Stuyvesant Town - Peter Cooper Village · 569 tips and reviews
Sergio Ponce de Leon: Must try the namesake slice, which uses a creamy artichoke-spinach sauce instead of tomato, but the Margherita and Sicilian are also very good. Have them cut in half so that they're easier to eat.
Marion Ong: For sure get the signature slice, the artichoke. If you have the stomach also get the crab and margherita pizzas, theyre legit.
travel42: No matter the time, be prepared to wait in line, but the specialty artichoke slice is worth it. The margherita is also delicious. Located near many East Village bars and open well past last call.
7. Olio e Piú
7.8
3 Greenwich Ave (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 144 tips and reviews
Jason Selss: Any pizzaiolo will enjoy Olio's Neapolitan pizza. The brick oven margherita pizza is delicious!
Luca DL: One of the top 5 best Italian pizza in town, if it's your first time here you should start with a Margherita Extra (with mozzarella di bufala) + Peroni or Moretti beer. Haters never had a real pizza.
Norma Courrier: Best Margherita and Carbonara! Staff is attentive and professional.
9. Capizzi
8.4
547 9th Ave (at W 40th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Hell's Kitchen · 109 tips and reviews
Pinkie Posh: I had the Margarita Pizza and it was great! Great Pizza c:
MoRiza: Start with the Margherita pie, close your eyes and randomly point on any two toppings. Enjoy!
Sal Candela: Every pie was better than the next... Margherita, Artichoke, Nonna, Prosciutto. If you like great pizza, you won’t be disappointed here.
Howcast: Margherita pizza is simple, delicious, and easy to make! Just pick up a few ingredients and you can make your own right at home! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tFCtiQbAKg Read more.
Aws Suhaibani: margherita 😍
New York Post: Lou Reed's partner Laurie Anderson tells us he liked the Margherita here. "When you use the right mozzarella, it’s amazing." Read more.
Mai Mai: Had a margherita and my son had a cheese. The slices were super crunchy, exactly the way we like it!!! Their foods are always tasty and absolutely fresh. Will definitely go back.
ayşe sonmaz: Best pizzas I've had in a long time. The sauce on margherita was tangy and that crust is addictive! Recommended!
Uygar Son: Wonderful atmosphere, great pizza, great service, we else can we say about hakki's? Our margherita pizza was simply delicious!
13. Lil' Frankie's
8.3
19 1st Ave (btwn E 1st & E 2nd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · East Village · 263 tips and reviews
Marie: I love it here! Everything is tasty and fresh. The rigatoni with baby meatballs is awesome as is the margherita pizza. Dishes are perfect for sharing. The Sixpoint Lil' Frankie's pale ale is a winner.
Michelle Alexander: Ouvo Pizza special is so good: margarita pizza + prosciutto + an egg in the center.
Marco Gomes: The best margherita pizza I had in NYC, comparing with Motorino, Eataly and some other places.
14. Prince Street Pizza
9.0
27 Prince St (btwn Mott & Elizabeth St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · NoLita · 371 tips and reviews
Delilah: Best pizza I've had in NYC. High quality ingredients and delicious combination of ingredients. My fave is Mercer Margherita!
Fiona: Order a margherita slice, have it warmed in the oven, and enjoy immediately. A perfect slice every time, grandma or regular!
Kathryn D: Classic or Margherita for vegetarians are both great.