2. Palma
8.9
28 Cornelia St (btwn Bleecker St & W 4th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 133 tips and reviews
Annie Jeng: The cauliflower appetizer is amazing. If it's not on the menu, ask for it - they'll make it for you. For the main course, the mushroom truffle fettuccine is the best!
Lori Luo: A cute, romantic atmosphere makes Palma an ideal date spot. Order the Caulifower appetizer, and any of their excellent pastas, such as the Fettuccine ai Funghi.
Nicolette Romero: The mushroom truffle fettuccine is to die for. Make sure to get a table in the adorable garden.
3. Pisticci Ristorante
9.1
125 La Salle St (at Broadway), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Harlem · 147 tips and reviews
Lizzy: Fettucine with mushrooms is amazing! House wine is also the way to go
The Corcoran Group: Very tasty, cozy and casual Italian restaurant. Try the Fettucine Ai Funghi, the House Meatballs Over Polenta, or share La Spaghettata with a large group!
jaz: Anything you get is delicious but spaghetti and meatballs is the best! Fettuccine al funghi as well is a winner :)
4. Max
7.7
134 W Broadway (at Duane St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Tribeca · 92 tips and reviews
Jay Harlow: If it's a special, get the fettucine with duck ragu.
Chad Miller: Max's fettucine is the best!
Sherry O: Tried & True- the lasagna, the lamb ragu and the fettucine, can't go at this place! Their location in the east village has an enclosed outdoor patio in the back. Lovely!
5. Cotenna
9.0
21 Bedford St (btwn Downing St and 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 241 tips and reviews
Nicolette Romero: Where to start...try the burrata with prosciutto. For pastas, the mushroom fettuccine and the garganelli osso buco were amazing.
Rebecca Amponsah: Bruce was amazing! Brussel sprouts great and fettuccine with mushroom + truffle sauce fantastic!
Celena Chan: 2nd time back at this cozy spot, had the carbonara and fungi fettuccini. Both excellent with the former being on the heavier side, but that's to be expected.
9. Isle of Capri
8.0
1028 3rd Ave (3rd Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 31 tips and reviews
Bruce Boillotat: The Fettuccini Alfredo is to die for
Alyssa B.: Homestyle Italian, very generous portions. I had the fettuccine alfredo, tiramisu, with wine and espresso all delicious! Charming interiors. Andres is the best!
Allen Michael: chicken parm is top notch
13. Bocca Restaurant
7.6
39E 19th St (Btw Broadway & Park), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Flatiron District · 46 tips and reviews
Jenny L.: House made fettuccine with jumbo lump crab meat and pesto is the best part of the meal last night, worth a return visit just for that dish!
Richard Revilla: Enjoyed a very authentic Italian meal. Meatballs where heavenly as well as the fettuccine. Sundays are half off wine bottles.
Christina DiRusso: Grab a table outside, order a glass of chianti and be charmed by the knowledgable Italian staff
14. Serafina Always
8.1
33 E 61st St (btwn Park & Madison Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 107 tips and reviews
Lee Hoffman: Fettuccini w cream sauce and chicken is fantastic
Sibel Akcekaya: Great choice if you want to get quick bite to eat, especially pastas are super fast and fresh fettuccine was super delicious
Alejandro: This is the best Serafina location, try their Veuve-Cliquot Rissotto is to die for! You can only find it at this location and trust me it's amazing!
15. Gene's
8.8
73 W 11th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 18 tips and reviews
Silene Lim: Nostalgic old school Italian with white table cloth, waiters with ties. We had the mesclun salad, Alfredo fettuccine and then the veal Marsala. All excellent. Highly recommend!
Mathias Jakobsen: have one of the best Perfect Manhattans without any fuzz or weirdness - just good!
Rob H: Literally a step back in time. Very few places like this left in the village. Get a Martini and watch the geriatrics.