1. Zero Otto Nove
7.3
15 W 21st St (Between 5th and 6th), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Flatiron District · 59 tips and reviews
Jared Brodsky: Try the La Riccardo - Absolutely unreal. Butternut squash puree, pencetta, and gorgonzola. Delicious.
NearSay NYC: Yummy! Bellissimo!! Butternut squash and smoked mozz are a must-have. Ask suggestions for a perfect wine pairing, everyone here is really helpful.
Joakim Thorén: I really enjoyed the butternut squash soup: Zuppa Di Cocozza
2. JoJo
8.5
160 E 64th St (btwn Lexington & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Upper East Side · 61 tips and reviews
New York Habitat: Who knew something so simple could be the best thing on the menu? Really, the butternut squash soup is outstanding, you'll regret not getting it!
Morgan McKee: Went with dad on a weds. Cute, townhouse vibe but quite loud! Food was of course great. Started with butternut squash soup and salmon for main. Great flavors and cook. Don’t miss the cocktails 🍹
Caroline Schulweis: Farm to table and beautiful new redesign in the last year. Great seafood salad, light butternut squash soup, salmon, and Brussels sprouts
4. Craft
9.0
43 E 19th St (btwn Park Ave S & Broadway), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 126 tips and reviews
Julie N: Venetian cocktail, roasted quail, Nantucket bay scallops, potatoes gratin, brussels sprouts, butternut squash purée, and the sorbet sampling...all incredible!
Dan Fradkin: Ok... Forgot to mention this. Best way to enjoy a meal here is family style. Several salads, several entres, lots of incredible sides such as the butternut squash purée and finally a choc. Soufflé
Avneesh Kohli: Incredible dining experience with exceptional service. Enjoyed the flat iron steak, potatoes, and butternut squash starter. Beautiful interior and ambience.
5. Juice Press
9.0
83 Murray St (btwn Greenwich St & W Broadway), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Tribeca · 11 tips and reviews
Wednesday: butternut squash && quinoa soup, almond butter acai bowl, schmear, strawberry superfood smoothie bowl,ginger fireball,omg!my favourite juice, genius blueberry protei.
Kelsey✨: Order the Blue Magic smoothie and substitute banana for cauliflower. Sounds weird, but tastes great! The cauliflower adds thickness w/o the extra sugar
Hyeji Kim: Delicious vegan raw food desserts smoothies and cold press juice. Pricey but so worth it
6. The Little Beet
8.4
1140 Broadway (at W 26th St), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · NoMad · 21 tips and reviews
Jenny Pierson: The butternut squash soup is delicious
Jenna Hahn: Great brownie and healthy vegan salads
Andrew Cerda: A faster option than sister restaurant "the little beet table" a few blocks away, the spring menu offers deliciously light rolls, bowl, and make your own plate options.
7. Sotto 13
8.7
140 W 13th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 118 tips and reviews
Mike Winston: The Butternut Squash Cannelloni is excellent and comes out from the pizza oven in bubbling skillet with tender noodle wrapped around creamy butternut squash puree with oozy, melted cheese.
Elizabeth Burstein: butternut squash risotto yum! they make their cocktails strong so make sure to ask for weaker. I had brooklyn basilica and then the smokey one.
Carole-Anne C: Amazing boozy brunch! Value for money!
Adam Hendricks: Im loving the butternut squash raviolis, perfect for my seasonal fall table.
Sam Winnick: Great little Italian market with tons of fresh made pasta and mozzarella.
Serious Eats: Italian deli with fresh pasta, standout hero sandwiches, and excellent fresh mozzarella.
11. Kashkaval Garden
9.0
852 9th Ave (btwn W 55th & W 56th St), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 106 tips and reviews
Heather Heck: All the skewers at delicious. Get 4 tapas for the price of 2 (highly recommend the walnut pepper, spinach & feta, hummus, and butternut squash tapas.) Fantastic wine selection and fondu!
Betty: Flavorful and satisfying tapas (4 for $15). Tiny space so get comfortable bumping elbows. Butternut tapenade, quinoa taboule, tzatziki, & chicken/filet mignon skewers will have me coming back!
Z: Garden gimlet & beet hummus are delish
14. Grandaisy Bakery
8.1
250 W Broadway (at Beach St), New York, NY
Bakery · Tribeca · 97 tips and reviews
Savannah Petrick: BREAD, potato pizza, butternut squash pizza, tomato pizza
Marinna Dudas: One of my favorite neighborhood spots for a quick bite. Best pizzas are cauliflower, zucchini and butternut squash. And their new caprese sandwich is phenomenal!
Valerie James: Cauliflower pizza and potato pizza! Amazing