Garlic New York Pizza Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

1. Garlic New York Pizza Bar

8.8
629 2nd Ave (btw 34 & 35 St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Murray Hill · 49 tips and reviews

Andrew C.Andrew Cassin: The buffalo Chicken pizza is the bomb

Andy B.Andy Burns: Buffalo chicken pizza...beeeaaatuuutiful

Craig P.Craig P: The buffalo chicken pizza is excellent!

Roma Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

2. Roma Pizza

7.3
1572 3rd Ave (at E 88th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper East Side · 64 tips and reviews

Meredith C.Meredith Cooklis: The Buffalo Chicken pizza will change your life!

Keith V.Keith Vander Leest: The buffalo chicken pizza is awesome

Daniel B.Daniel Bishop: Gotta try the buffalo chicken pizza! It is awesome!!

Proto's Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

3. Proto's Pizza

7.2
50 2nd Ave (btwn E 2nd & 3rd St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 19 tips and reviews

R. Philip S.R. Philip Stevenson: The Buffalo chicken pizza is really awesome.

Allison Y.Allison Y: Buffalo chicken pizza!!

Juan V.Juan Velasquez: Definitely try Proto's fresh chicken parm sandwich on his homemade bread. Don't forget to eat his buffalo chicken pizza or his vodka slice. One of the best I've ever had. And I love pizza.

Fumo is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

4. Fumo

8.6
1600 Amsterdam Ave (139th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Harlem · 27 tips and reviews

Girish K.Girish Kumar: One of the must visit places in harlem! They got great pizza and salads. Try out their brunch, buffalo pizza and spicy calamari.

Brett W.Brett Williams: Baked Clams, Artichokes, and Calamari are all amazing

Grace W.Grace Whitworth: So excited! The arugula salad is fresh and the lemon olive oil dressing is a perfect match. I ordered the chicken francese with veggies paired with the sauvignon blanc and it was delicious!

Siena Pizza And Cannoli is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

5. Siena Pizza And Cannoli

8.0
14 Rector St, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Financial District · 2 tips and reviews

Celestino M.Celestino Martinez: Great buffalo pizza

Joan B.Joan Barroso Garrido: Buenas porciones de pizza

Best Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

6. Best Pizza

7.7
1038 1st Ave (at E 57th St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 15 tips and reviews

Oz Moving & StorageOz Moving & Storage: "This small hole in the wall with barely any place to sit always has fresh and great pizza. The Buffalo chicken pizza is a standout, and their white slice is awesome too." - Nimrod, Oz Sales Manager

Bibi M.Bibi Miller: Slices are awesome & eclectic. They do cracker thin crust, and it's Amazing.

David G.David Greenberger: The place lives up to its name. 1 of the top 3 slices I've had in NYC. No need to get fancy, the plain and mini pepperoni slices are out of this world.

Famous Famiglia Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

7. Famous Famiglia Pizza

7.3
1248 Lexington Ave (Between E. 84th & E. 85th Street), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper East Side · 5 tips and reviews

dawn.in.newyorkdawn.in.newyork: What a nice pizza slice place which has a clean and spacious seating area. Plus it's located on Lexington ave nearby 86th subway station. Buffalo chicken pizza was delicious.

John C.John Cline: The margherita pizza is way better than it has any right being

Ritwik D.Ritwik Dey: Basic pizza. There’s a 10 min inch personal pizza that’s perfect for my 3 year-old.

Emily West Village is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

8. Emily West Village

9.1
35 Downing St (at Bedford St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · West Village · 147 tips and reviews

Kevin C.Kevin Caballes: Dinner starts at 5 if you want to grab a seat. The 'for the nyugen' is a fun and tasty take on a buffalo chicken pizza.

M N.M N: Burger is the best in the business and a must have. Any pizza with honey is always money.

Eric A.Eric Abergel: If you are a fan of Emily or Emmy Squared (or delicious pizza) then this spot is the best of both worlds! Delicious and creative pizza and food in great West Village space. Loved the Emily square pie

La Traviata is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

9. La Traviata

7.3
101 W 68th St (btwn Columbus Ave & Broadway), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Lincoln Square · 28 tips and reviews

Matty M.Matty Magnin: The buffalo chicken pizza is fantastic, don't forget to add a side of blue cheese for dipping. They also don't have a minimum for credit cards. Great place overall.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: A dumpy, hole-in-the-wall serving delicious slices of pizza (get two slices and a can of soda for $5). The Chicken Parmesan sandwich is big enough for two – order extra sauce.

Tonnvane W.Tonnvane Wiswell: A perfect place for a pre-ballet slice.

Rosella's Pizzeria is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

10. Rosella's Pizzeria

7.4
164 William St (btw Ann & Beekman), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Financial District · 50 tips and reviews

Saager M.Saager Mhatre: The Buffalo Chicken pizza is just sublime.

Joanne B.Joanne Bouillon: The fresh eggplant pizza hits the spot. My second fave behind Gaby's.

Mandar M.Mandar M: Get the eggplant slice and dance to 90s dance music and freestyle ., they just don't make it like this anymore .. Both the pizza and the music .. This place rocks !

2 Bros. Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

11. 2 Bros. Pizza

7.7
557 8th Ave (at W 38th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Garment District · 92 tips and reviews

Paul GPaul G: Buffalo chicken pizza ...so damn good!

Stephanie L.Stephanie Littler: Best pizza I had whilst visiting, definitely recommend!

Allison F.Allison Finazzo: Can't beat dollar slices!

Big Al's Chicago Style Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

12. Big Al's Chicago Style Pizza

7.6
9 Thames St, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Financial District · 8 tips and reviews

Vincent G.Vincent G.: Great food, big slices of homemade pizzas, great calzone and huge pasta ! Definitely recommend this place !

John P.John Paterakis: Both Chicago and New York-style options

CB J.CB Johnson: Not really Chicago style. It's the worst stereotype of what New Yorkers think Chicago Pizza is - NY Pizza with a bunch of extra bread.

East Village Pizza is one of The 13 Best Places for Buffalo Pizza in New York City.

13. East Village Pizza

7.5
145 1st Ave (at E 9th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 47 tips and reviews

Graham S.Graham Smith: 5$ for 2 slices and a soda will be ready quick, will fill you up, and their plain slices are great. Great NY-minute meal.

Mucous LavenderMucous Lavender: They have pizza

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Come in for a celebration! For their 18th anniversary, East Village Pizza & Kebabs is serving 2 regular slices + 16oz soda for only $5.