Mr. Z's -Old Town is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

1. Mr. Z's -Old Town

7.6
501 Southard St (at Duval St.), Key West, FL
Pizzeria · 57 tips and reviews

Ben G.Ben Guzman: Cheesesteak with onions, mushrooms, and whiz is great!

Bryan K.Bryan Kihlmire: If your getting a cheesesteak, the cheese fries are a must as well!!!

Carolyn H.Carolyn Hoffmann: Great pizza and cheesesteaks! Also, great pork roll sandwich!!

Prime 951 Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

2. Prime 951 Steak House

8.1
951 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 16 tips and reviews

Elizabeth B.Elizabeth Bigelow: Best steak in Key West! The staff is great too!!

Elena B.Elena Barba: Steak of course is the best..love the decor.

CentralTexas R.CentralTexas RoadRelics: Truly one of the best Prime Ribeyes I've ever had, will not hesitate to come back again, guaranteed!!

El Siboney Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

3. El Siboney Restaurant

8.8
900 Catherine St (Margaret St.), Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 142 tips and reviews

Courtney H.Courtney Harden: #7 (siboney steak) and the roast pork are DELISH!! I highly recommend either! And don't forget the sangria to wash it down!!

Sean B.Sean B.: The el Siboney, flank steak, maduros, black beans, and yellow rice are a must try.

Cassandra T.Cassandra Toppino: The best Cuban food in town. The siboney steak is my favorite although the breaded steak is a close second. Instead of black beans I have been ordering the red beans and they are now my favorite.

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

4. Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

8.1
1007 Simonton St (at Truman Ave.), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Katy F.Katy Ford: All the steaks and shrimp are divine!

Nicola S.Nicola Setford: Best meal we had on our trip. Great steak and shrimp and lovely cocktails. Reasonably priced too. Would highly recommend. You won't leave hungry.

Carlos R.Carlos Robles: Great spot for steaks!!!

El Meson de Pepe Restaurant & Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

5. El Meson de Pepe Restaurant & Bar

8.3
410 Wall St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 103 tips and reviews

The DurbsThe Durbs: Don't miss this place! I had the Cuban steak sandwich, phenomenal! You can't go wrong here. FYI They add 18% gratuity automatically.

Nikki H.Nikki Haley: Awesome food. My kid's steak was the best steak i've had in a long time! They also have bathrooms to use if you're hanging out at Mallory Square and you need to go!

Aaron S.Aaron Scott: Best food I've had on the Island. The skirt steak #63 is amazing.

Pepe's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

6. Pepe's Cafe

8.5
806 Caroline St (btwn Williams & Margaret St), Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 97 tips and reviews

Patrick K.Patrick Keane: Best breakfast in Key West! Make sure you get the bread special! The chili is great for lunch or dinner. And the make an awesome steak at a good value! Don't forget their Wacky Pack!

Kayla B.Kayla BeeMuddy: Best ribeye EVER. So happy I almost cried.

Berneice F.Berneice Ferber: 2nd time here. had the chopped steak dinner. it is very good. wish i could think outside the box and order something different.

Latitudes Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

7. Latitudes Restaurant

8.8
Sunset Key, Sunset Key, FL
American Restaurant · 71 tips and reviews

Gayle B.Gayle Bailey: Delicious skirt steak was unbelievable and the atmosphere was over the top!

Kat N.Kat Newbold: Latiudes is amazing and worth every penny! My husband and I had an amazing romantic meal here! The key west shrimp appetizer was amazing as was the perfectly cooked skirt steak!! Yum!

Beth A.Beth Ann: Vanilla mudslide was de-lish! Skirt steak was amazinggg, banana tart tatan was fabulous and service was impeccable! Worth every penny!

Caroline's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

8. Caroline's Cafe

8.2
310 Duval St (at Caroline St), Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 98 tips and reviews

Don B.Don Becker: Best cheese steak outside of Philly.

Jenn T.Jenn Tofanelli: Lettuce wrap salad. Or order the cheese steak except with chicken. Super delish. And fantastic people watching.

Kelly R.Kelly Russell Ranft: Caribbean steak is flipping delicious!!!

Commodore Steak & Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

9. Commodore Steak & Lobster House

7.6
220 Margaret Street, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 18 tips and reviews

Jake M.Jake Mathers: Dinner for 2 for us included a delmonico steak with caesar salad- we added a shrimp scampi side for a perfect pairing- worth the flavor sensation!

Wayne T.Wayne Tess: Disappointed, carpaccio beef and Caesar salad had no flavor. Steak was medium well instead of medium. Wouldn't go back. We don't mind spending money on good food but this was not worth it.

Mark H.Mark Hendrix: Our group had a wide variety and we all agreed that the fried shrimp, fried lobster tail and their steaks were great!

New York Pasta Garden is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

10. New York Pasta Garden

8.4
1075 Duval St, Key West, FL
Italian Restaurant · 53 tips and reviews

Moises R.Moises Rivera: Excellent ambience, outdoor seating and the sirloin tip salad is amazing!

Kate W.Kate Weston: Great food! Steak salad rocked! Parrots are a fun addition! We ate with Lula!

Esra E.Esra Ekici: Excellent quality food! Skirt steak and caprice salad to die for!!! Friendly service and good ambiance with good selection of music.

Cafe Marquesa is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

11. Cafe Marquesa

8.7
600 Fleming St, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Steve M.Steve Mouzon: Both flatiron steak and yellowtail were excellent. Can't go wrong with either.

Rosie M.Rosie M: Top notch in Key West. Menu changes daily. Great atmosphere. 1 block off of Duval but it feels like 10miles. Like a place in the West Village of Manhattan.

FranFran: Save room for the Key Lime Napoleon for dessert!

Kim's Kuban is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

12. Kim's Kuban

8.2
2302 N Roosevelt Blvd (at 5th St), Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Bing F.Bing Futch: Steak, egg and cheese sandwich = heaven!

Stephanie ☥ S.Stephanie ☥ Swogger: Great cold Cuban sandwiches and Café con Leche!

Way B.Way Benjamin: Affordable and real to the chase. The fish tacos are delicious, *corn* or flour tortillas your pick. I went back after I tried Garbo Grill because it’s more authentic and a bang for the bucks!

Hard Rock Cafe Key West is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

13. Hard Rock Cafe Key West

7.9
313 Duval St, Key West, FL
Theme Restaurant · 91 tips and reviews

Torsten W.Torsten Wolf: try the sirloin steak.awesome

Jose S.Jose Sanchez: Worst hard rock ever, had the salmon and it was dry and burned; wife had the steak and was dry and tasteless.

EppoEppo: Realy good New York Steak!

Outback Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

14. Outback Steakhouse

7.4
3230 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 25 tips and reviews

In The K.In The Keys: Every single time we come here, the steaks are undercooked. Way undercooked. Unless you like it raw, blue, and still cold in the middle. EVERYTIME.

Mike W.Mike Wilbur: This is a typical, fine American Steak chain restaurant....nothing fancy but a reasonable value.

Samuel F.Samuel Faria: The restaurant is perfect. There are a waiter very good. CJay. Thank you for your care.

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa is one of The 15 Best Places for Steak in Key West.

15. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

8.3
601 Front St, Key West, FL
Hotel · 29 tips and reviews

Aaron K.Aaron Kraus: Mark the bartender is the best Key West resource and his knowledge of New York, music, and steaks is impressive.

Robbie A.Robbie Amodei: .....the best hotel in Key West! And perfect spot for Sunset celebration.

vicequeenmariavicequeenmaria: Cozy resort on the gulf, close to all the action but in a quiet street. Ask for a gulf view room and treat yourself to a massage. Daily sunset sails from the dock.