2. Eataly
9.0
43 E Ohio St (at N Wabash Ave), Chicago, IL
Gourmet Store · Near North Side · 409 tips and reviews
Daniel Chao: Grab a table upstairs and wind down with wine and an assortment of cheese! The sweet milk gelato is a must try!!
Chris Nesladek: Chicago outpost offers a sugarific first floor of Nutella, Chocolates, and Gelato not to be missed even if you eat with your eyes.
Jen Ostafinski: Gelato, cheese, wine, pasta anything you try is amazing
6. RPM Italian
8.9
52 W Illinois St (at N Dearborn St), Chicago, IL
Italian Restaurant · Near North Side · 238 tips and reviews
Kate Osborne: The coconut gelato is worth every calorie!!
Joni Bradley: Must order the klug peaches with pistachio cake and gelato! But skip the coffee-I ordered decaf and it must have been old because it was undrinkable.
Andriana Albamonte: Order family style and share! Don't miss the lobster caprese, zucchini fritti, king crab pasta and eggplant parm and dessert! The rice pudding gelato is amazing. Our waiter was great too!
Mary Jo Chrabasz: The gelato is amazing!!
Candace W: Love the gelato! Also they will cook your meat for you at the meat counter. Great samples throughout out the store. Very roomy!
MJ Walters: Best Mariano's I've been to yet. Ginormous lot, big store, lots of room and much more product. Try the trail mix bar and the fresh juices.
10. Quartino
8.8
626 N State St (at W Ontario St), Chicago, IL
Italian Restaurant · Near North Side · 345 tips and reviews
Sue Ellen Tetlak: Everything I ate was awesome, but the raviloli was completely out of this world! The gelato also was amazing!
Christy: Penne alla Vodka all the way, I get it every time! For desserts, coppa al banana, the chocolate cake, the zeppole or the gelato - all are great with their coffee. But really, everything is delicioso!
Zeke Franco: Try the Panino al Gelato Limone - Lemon cream gelato sandwich with lemon curd, whipped cream, & lemon chips. Amazing dessert; the best I've had in a while.
11. Amorino
8.3
38 S Michigan Ave (at E Monroe St), Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · The Loop · 3 tips and reviews
First Last: Just perfect! Ice cream, Gelato, coffee, crepes and more.
Alison: Friendly staff, fast service, and delicious gelato!
Elizabeth Armas: The place, the flavors, the service, the location, hours, all is good here! I truly has a blast from The times I spent in Italy. Definitely I recommend this place and will come here again 😍
12. Bar Siena
8.4
832 West Randolph Street (Green), Chicago, IL
Italian Restaurant · Fulton Market · 46 tips and reviews
PureWow: Bar Siena offers Nutella calzones. Stuffed with vanilla-bean gelato and hazelnuts, the flaky treats are slathered in the maddeningly addictive chocolate sauce.
Jeiran Hasan: Went to the wide window for desserts, but fast service and delicious gelato. Highly recommend!
C Rey: Feels like a bar first place with food riding in the passenger seat. Try the pizza or short rib lasagna but save room for the wildly delicious dessert menu full of Bombobar pastries and coffees.
14. Pompei
8.4
1531 W Taylor St (btwn S Ashland Ave & S Laflin St), Chicago, IL
Italian Restaurant · University Village - Little Italy · 45 tips and reviews
A-Bomb: They have great gelato and rotate some of their flavors, so there's usually something new to try. And it's only $3.06 for four scoops!
Mike Pietrusinski: If you are looking for Italian Fast Food..this is the place to go...I have not had a bad meal here from traditional paninis to their pizza streudels...and their gelato rocks too!
Michelle: The pizza Pompei might be the best slice in town! Similar to tomato pie for you east coasters!
15. VinnyD's
7.7
1709 W Division St (Paulina), Chicago, IL
Snack Place · East Ukrainian Village · 3 tips and reviews
Diego Rodriguez: Amazing Gelato and great friendly service
BigTab R.N.: Get the Italian Cookie gelato! It’s delicious! 🍨
Matthew McKee: Hot dogs are classic Chicago style Vienna Beef dogs at a reasonable price. The Vinny Spinny (think Blizzard) is a perfect summer treat made with old school, high milk fat, quality.