Paula Haney banana cream pie alone made her a farmers’-market celebrity, helping build the funds and confidence to launch a West Town pie shop in fall 2009. Read more.
The Sugar Cream pie is to die for, and their rhubarb is also amazing!
I'm a banana pie connoisseur, so as an expert I can safely attest this to be the best banana cream pie to grace this planet.
Serving Biscuits as well as Shaker Lemon Pie, Chocolate Orange Pie and Banana Cream Pie.
Nice place, full off interesting people, nice crews, I tried cafe and cream pie with cafe and it was awsome
AWESOME little cafe focused mostly on pies and biscuits. The biscuits are large, soft and fresh, ask for the pomegranate & pear jam, it is so delicious. The banana cream pie is off the chart good.
Filet. Stroganoff. Creamed spinach. Chocolate cream pie. So much yum.
Baked crab cake, oysters, bacon roasted tomato salad, short rib beef stroganoff, steak frites, and chocolate cream pie! Can't wait to go back!!
This was legitimately one of the best meals I have ever had. The steak frites were absolutely delicious. And don’t skip on dessert. The chocolate cream pie was to die for.
Coconut cream pie concrete. Eat it!
Try the coconut cream pie concrete. Seriously. -FS Read more.
feeling adventurous? Try the Tabasco Cream Pie...fluffy creamy goodness with the tiniest kick at the end
Coffee toffee pie. You won't regret it. :-)
First Slice is not just a great place to get a slice of pie. Buy healthy meals for your busy family, and you'll pay for the same meals to go to Chicago’s hungry and homeless. Read more.
The peanut butter fudge pie and the bananas foster cream pie together is known as the "Elvis." Filet was perfection and really dug their crumbly mashed potatoes. Stone crab appetizer is so worth it!
Order the banana cream pie - simply amazing!
What can you say? It's my favorite meal in the country whether in Chi or Miami. Stone crabs, crispy hash browns, creamed spinach, slaw and signature key lime pie pictured above.
I love the Banana Cream Pie Blizzard.
Chocolate extreme with chocolate ice cream. Yes!
Mint Oreo Blizzard!
My favorites are the lobster mac, bone in kona steak, seafood tower, and the coconut cream pie.
You know when you're full and you still keep eating? That's this place! Service is phenomenal, food to die for! Crab cakes have chunks of crab you can actually see, lobster mac amazing! Steak perfect!
Lobster Mac!!!!!!
Try the new chocolate cream pie here.
One of their classics is the Chicago style dog. Try just for curiosity. All the other dishes in the menu are great! Loved Ralph’s cocktail!
I fell in I've with the lobster bisque
My friend recommended the banana cream pie omgosh its wicked gd
Banana cream pie! 🙋
Banana pudding is a must. I can't pass this place without getting the urge.
I had "The Pit Master" sandwitch and the "Banana Cream Pie" - it was great!
Award winner chef. Smokes meats on site, great sides too.
Sauces on every table: After much taste-testing, I liked the Eastern North Carolina Vinegar the most
Banana Cream Napoleon (Warm Caramel, Phyllo, Whipped Cream)
Strawberries & Crème Brûlée (Strawberry Sorbet)
Halibut Fish & Chips (Sauce Gribiche, Cornichon)
I would definitely recommend the chicken run ranch burger with a delicious watermelon fresca as your drink! For dessert, I recommend the oatmeal cream pie!!
Portabello and sausage burger is super delicious! Watermelon Fresca drink is the bomb!!
Get a side of chipotle sauce with the sweet potato fries.
My dear baby lord, the oatmeal cream pie shake is divine.
Best fries and one of the tastiest hamburgers in town
Fellow burger-loving friends, you will have a tough time finding a superior sub-$5 fast-food cheeseburger in Chicago than the one served here. I do proclaim this one of the city's greatest patties. Read more.
Try the Greek skillet. The lamb is always tender and the feta cheese is always fresh. Can't go wrong!
Great French Toast! The service is always good.
., the coke Is fire!!
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA