Bagel Jay's is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

1. Bagel Jay's

7.2
2130 Delaware Ave (at Great Arrow Ave), Buffalo, NY
Bagel Shop · Park Meadow · 21 tips and reviews

Jae R.Jae Rodriguez: BLT's on everything bagels delicious

Caryn P.Caryn Poland: Whole wheat everything bagels are delish!

Chuck H.Chuck Hoskins: Quality takes time, bagel jays is worth waiting for. Try the Whole wheat everything

Tim Hortons is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

2. Tim Hortons

7.7
3470 Main St (at Capen Blvd), Buffalo, NY
Coffee Shop · University · 16 tips and reviews

AlexAlex: They can't put together a bagel belt or make oatmeal without drowning it in gallons of water. Better off going to dunkin down the street.

Molly M.Molly Mac: Get your breakfast sandwich on the new pretzel bagel ♥

Parinitha M.Parinitha Marnekar: Cafe mocha and an jalapeño bagel..

Elmwood Village Farmers Market is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

3. Elmwood Village Farmers Market

8.5
Elmwood Ave (at Bidwell Pkwy), Buffalo, NY
Farmers Market · West Side · 11 tips and reviews

Troy F.Troy Fallin: T-Meadow farms had whole pork belly today. Time to smoke my own bacon. Also grabbed some fresh duck eggs and an everything bagel from Bread Hive.

Eric A.Eric Amodeo: The Pasta Peddler has the best pasta, sauce and ravioli!

Rebecca DeckerRebecca Decker: Get cheese from First Light, beer from Community Beer Works, yogurt from White Cow and a whole wheat cinnamon roll from Five Points.

Breadhive Bakery is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

4. Breadhive Bakery

7.0
402 Connecticut St, Buffalo, NY
Bakery · West Side · 7 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: Rosemary sea salt bagel is amazing. The Aaliyah is where it's at- homemade sausage. Coffee great too ($1 refills).

Michael M.Michael Marranzini: Seems like a homey place.

Devan E.Devan Egan: Chocolate Salted Rye❤️🥇

SPoT Coffee is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

5. SPoT Coffee

7.5
227 Delaware Ave (at W Chippewa St), Buffalo, NY
Coffee Shop · Central Business District · 76 tips and reviews

Sam R.Sam Robbins: Idle what it is about their bagels, but they're freaking awesome. Maybe it's the butter. Gotta be the butter...

Matthew S.Matthew Sheppard: Awesome place to hang out and have a coffee. The breakfast wrap was immense!

Nicole J.Nicole Johnson: If you need coffee on the corner of Delaware and Chippewa and choose Starbucks over Spot, you are what's wrong with America.

The Black Sheep is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

6. The Black Sheep

8.0
367 Connecticut St (at 14th St), Buffalo, NY
Eastern European Restaurant · West Side · 12 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: "Then there was the sticky toffee pudding, a Bistro Europa gem. It’s like butter making love to caramel under a whipped cream canopy. Expressed as cake." Buffalo News. 100% correct. YUM

Marge N.Marge Novara: Pierogis were over the top delicious. I had chicken breast on a purée of vegetables. It was great! The sticky toffee pudding with their coffee ended aa incredible meal.

Steve P.Steve Poland: French fries were amazing. Love the charcuterie (3 meats). Homemade bread. Need to try the clams. Great fancy cocktails, beers and wine selection. Love the ambiance.

Caffe Aroma is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

7. Caffe Aroma

8.0
957 Elmwood Ave (at Bidwell Pkwy), Buffalo, NY
Café · Albright · 28 tips and reviews

Emma F.Emma Fabian: Beer or coffee? Great problem to have and great place to have it.

Social YeahSocial Yeah: Longest running independently owned coffee shop in the area!

Adrian R.Adrian R.: Iced tea vat may not be cleaned regularly, so taste it before you leave because it gets funky. They sometimes pour one tea in with another (or iced coffee), so another reasn to taste.

Osteria 166 is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

8. Osteria 166

8.3
166 Franklin St (at W Mohawk St), Buffalo, NY
Trattoria · Central Business District · 26 tips and reviews

Anthony C.Anthony Crain: The service here is above and beyond amazing. The chef even came out to discuss options and pick food with me, then we crafted our own taste test experiment!

Chris S.Chris Smith: Excellent service, good food, solid wine list, and the friendliest owner in the city. A great place for happy hour and dinner.

Rachel G.Rachel Gottlieb: If you're unhappy about anything, Nick will bend over backwards to fix it. Plus the food is great.

SPoT Coffee Elmwood Cafe is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

9. SPoT Coffee Elmwood Cafe

7.5
765 Elmwood Ave (at Cleveland Ave.), Buffalo, NY
Coffee Shop · Delaware - West Ferry · 92 tips and reviews

Jessica Z.Jessica Zak: Pizza bagels!!!!!!!

Cory H.Cory Holzerland: Don't eat pizza bagels outside. The birds will attack in formation!

Collin S.Collin Sabers: The veggie cream cheese is out of this world! I recommend this to everyone!

The Lunch Box is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

10. The Lunch Box

7.6
465 Main St (in Lafayette Court Building), Buffalo, NY
Sandwich Spot · Central Business District · 7 tips and reviews

Laura S.Laura Suttell: Hummus veggie wraps and salads (especially good balsamic dressing) are remarkable.

patricia f.patricia frey: Expensive and asks for tips for over the counter service.

patricia f.patricia frey: Inefficient setup!

Patina 250 is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

11. Patina 250

7.4
250 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY
New American Restaurant · Central Business District · 4 tips and reviews

AmateurConciergeAmateurConcierge: Nice hotel resto but the chicken salad I ordered was flavorless

Richard R.Richard Rogers: The drinks were okay service was so so.

Bradley H.Bradley Homer: Irish Be Brunch 🌈🍾🥂🇮🇪💚🤍🧡🥃🍲🍞🍴

Mykonos Express is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

12. Mykonos Express

7.4
1066 Elmwood Ave (at Bird Ave), Buffalo, NY
Greek Restaurant · West Side · 15 tips and reviews

Mykal M.Mykal Modrall: Bacon cheeseburger poutine is excellent.

Jose Ricardo A.Jose Ricardo Alvira Ramos: I Love It!

Josh K.Josh Kruk: The cook in the Yankees flat brim hat makes a killer pita.

JT’s Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Buffalo.

13. JT’s Restaurant

7.1
905 Elmwood Ave (at W Delevan Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · Albright · 3 tips and reviews

Emma B.Emma Balkin: You're the Spritz cocktail, 👍🏻

Emma B.Emma Balkin: Takes too long for a table, even with a reservation. If I can't get a table for 8:30, don't let me make a reservation for 8:30 and then make me wait at the bar until after 9.....

Bradley H.Bradley Homer: 🥂🍕🥗🥀🥂