Try the Pizza With Pepperoni, Garlic And Basil - This place really really is amazing. Not sure it's worth the two hour wait, but it is one of the best pies I've had.
Top 5 pizza places for me. Get there before 6 or expect a 2 hour wait. Pizza is excellent but the calzone is the real star. Perfect meal: pepperoni pizza and shallot, basil, garlic calzone. It's BYOB!
Second time such amazing vibes. Pepperoni was amazing. Calzone is also worth it. Still top pizza place for me.
Four cheese and pepperoni drizzled with a locally made honey is delicious. Neapolitan Meatball is yummy. Lunchbox cocktail is interesting in a good way. Service and atmosphere were phenomenal.
Truly some of the best pizza we've had in Brooklyn. Come with some friends so you can try a few - but mainly the meatball, the arugula with prosciutto, & the four cheese with pepperoni are must-try's!
Really enjoyed the four cheese pizza with pepperoni. Scrumptious :)
The Hellboy squared aka the Freddy Prince with Pepperoni and hot honey drizzle is by far the best slice here
Pepperoni slice for $4.25. On the expensive side but worth every penny
Get the Mootz - fresh & grande mozzarella, romano, garlic & a drizzle of olive oil & the Freddy Pepperoni Square - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, romano & pepperoni on a sesame seed Sicilian crust!
Homemade sauce, fresh mozzarella, soft ricotta, spicy pepperoni, salty capers, hand-cut mushrooms and basil decorate the best offerings. There's also a white pizza (no sauce) and calzones to nosh on.
The tomato sauce, pizza dough and mozzarella tastes very fresh. I recommend pepperoni as a topping, slamming!
New York Cosmos forward Peri Marosevic loves the original pepperoni pizza.
The Luca with Buffalo mozz, sauce, and basil, or The Wrestler with mozz, pepperoni, sausage, and prosciutto -- are some pretty mind-bending creations. Read more.
Love this place! Order a pizza and an app or pasta for 2 ppl, two+ pizzas for any party larger than that. The Colonie with pepperoni, pickled chilis & honey is A++, as is the bucatini and the cheeses!
Go here. Get the Colony (sauce, peppers, pepperoni, and honey) and the PXG (tomatillo sauce and 'nduja sausage). Give Emily a hug. Don't talk to me until you do.
cash only folks and be sure to try the pepperoni well done
Try the Pepperoni Pizza - Awesome
Food Network's Top Five Resturants: #1 Best Pizza - mushroom and pepperoni pie
If you like a little spice on your pizza, go for the Roni Supreme. It has "lots of pepperoni" & the calabrian chiles give it a perfect kick.
Go downstairs and split a pepperoni pizza and the Big Matt burger. The burger is outstanding, double patty, emmy sauce, cheese, pickles on a pretzel bun.
Pizza is indulgent: like the best Pizza Hut pan pizza ever (pepperoni and neopolitan win), spicy chicken sandwich was quite bomb as well. 9.6 is early opening hype tho
The margherita pizza with added pepperoni is spectacular. I don't usually really like pepperoni but theirs is amazing - crispy, thin and delicious.
Get the margarita pizza and add pepperoni 🍕🍕😋😋
Try the white pizza but also add pepperoni for some spice
Pretty good grandmas style pepperoni slice, but not up there with either Paulie Gees or Prince Street
Way better than Emmy Squared. Enjoyed the pepperoni and buffalo chicken. A “half square” is plenty for one, maybe even two people if you’re not crazy hungry.
Love this spot! Detroit style is amazing. Pepperoni 🔥
Think pizza only tastes great from wood or coal burning ovens? Think again. Fresh, quality ingredients imported from Italy set these pies apart - try the real, thick-cut pepperoni or fresh artichokes.
Best pizza in Brooklyn: Get here mid week & mid afternoon, less wait. Get a pie with porcini, pepperoni and/or sausage toppings
Excellent. I actually preferred the plain cheese over the toppings I got (tried pepperoni and mushroom). Takes a while for them to make.
Best slices in the city! Even the traditional pepperoni pizza is out of this world.
The best pepperoni I've had.
Very good pepperoni pizza!
Try the pepperoni rolls.
Bruschetta was delicious along with the mozzarella sticks, the Philly cheese steak pizza was out of this world 😍😍 the pepperoni and sausage was ok..
Very solid "local" pizza place. Nothing newfangled, just very good pizza, particularly IMO their white slice (try it with pepperoni) and their eggplant parm slice.
The name isn't too far off. The white slice has a sesame crust and the pepperoni is oversized
Delivery holds up the tasty crispy goodness. Try the pickled veggies and add pepperoni. Yum. Also can never go wrong with a slice of the seasonal veg - thats 2 veg tips from a carnivore. Best!
White pie - Collab between Brooklyn Star and a Roberta's alum is the next evolution of the NY slice joint ... from the sesame seeds sprinkled on the white pie, to cuts of pepperoni, ...
To do it right: pepperoni and shallots plus the complimentary garlic and basil.
Mushroom and pepperoni TO Best Pizza 2019
Super cozy and delicious. Only pizza on the menu, but it's excellent.
Regular large pepperoni and you won't go wrong. Say hi to Mr. Grimaldi--he's super nice.
Pizza Margherita with pepperoni and sausage. For starters house meatballs.
Excellent pizza! Go for the margherita with pepperoni and no.9 :) just be prepared to wait in line coz a lot of people flock here.
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA