Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

1. Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies

9.0
185 Van Dyke St (at Ferris St), Brooklyn, NY
Pie Shop · Red Hook · 114 tips and reviews

Cheapeats I.Cheapeats Inc: The best Key Lime Pie this side of the Mason Dixon.

J R.J Ro: possibly the best key lime pie sans florida pies. $10 min credit card. do it!

Renae M.Renae Mason: The original key lime pie is amazing. Forget the frozen on a stick thing.

Culture: An American Yogurt Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

2. Culture: An American Yogurt Company

8.7
331 5th Ave (btwn 3rd & 4th St), Brooklyn, NY
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Central Slope · 96 tips and reviews

jessica m. h.jessica m. hintermeister: it's all about the key lime pie topping! bonus: all organic and whole milk version option for optimal creaminess;)

Andrea O.Andrea Olalia: Try the Key Lime Pie Frozen Yogurt - #tart #fresh #healthy

Jake S.Jake Siegal: Original with Key Lime Pie topping with extra graham crackers.

Traif is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

3. Traif

9.0
229 S 4th St (btwn Roebling & Havemeyer St), Brooklyn, NY
Tapas Restaurant · Williamsburg · 285 tips and reviews

Yi Jia C.Yi Jia Chou: Had the tasting menu and It was one of the best meals I've ever had! Highlights were the bacon doughnuts, key lime pie (made by chef's mom I'm told), pork belly and the biggest foie gras I ever saw

Jackie L.Jackie Lau: Try the Bacon Doughnuts and Key Lime Pie!!

Carolyn T.Carolyn T: Get: Red Pearl, broccoli rabe, bigeye tuna, bacon doughnuts and the underplayed key lime pie. Then: go home happy.

Louis Valentino Jr Park & Pier is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

4. Louis Valentino Jr Park & Pier

9.1
Coffey St & Ferris St, Brooklyn, NY
Park · Red Hook · 34 tips and reviews

Globetrottergirls D.Globetrottergirls Dani: Great sunset views. Tranquil & peaceful, barely anyone here. Pack a picnic or grab a key lime pie on a stick from Steve's, but don't forget the mosquito repellent 😊

Ben M.Ben Mackey: Great place for a picnic, or to sit while eating your key lime pie.

NYC ParksNYC Parks: At Valentino Pier, you can watch the Staten Island Ferry pass by the city's best front-facing view of the Statue of Liberty. Read more.

Pilar Cuban Eatery is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

5. Pilar Cuban Eatery

8.4
397 Greene Ave (at Bedford Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Cuban Restaurant · Bedford-Stuyvesant · 90 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Informal and small eatery serving up the best Pressed Cuban Sandwiches and Pernil - also try the Elena Ruth and finish it off with a slice of Key Lime Pie.

David S.David Snyder: Vaca Frita on Wednesdays, Boliche on Saturdays, key lime pie always.

nikkinikki: guava anything and key lime pie are killer. never forget the maduros!

Mia's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

6. Mia's Bakery

8.4
139 Smith St (Bergen St.), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Boerum Hill · 46 tips and reviews

Michelle L.Michelle Leeds: My favorite key lime pie (it's less tart than most). Chocolate fudge cake is pretty delicious too.

Brandon F.Brandon F.: Excellent selection of pastries, cakes, pies, and everything else. Particularly fond of the key lime pie and lemon meringue.

CaseyCasey: I had a very cozy vegetarian bite before an event last night. Very friendly staff and tasty pastries!

Dolly's Italian Ices is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

7. Dolly's Italian Ices

8.0
5805 Avenue T (at E 58th St), Brooklyn, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Flatlands · 20 tips and reviews

KateKate: Key lime pie is amazing

Nicky R.Nicky Rago: Best ices over a 100 flavors of ices & ice cream!!! Try them all

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Coming here for Italian ices makes us feel like a kid again. They have such a great variety of flavors so it's hard to pick our favorites, but we love the graham cracker crunch & red velvet the most.

Pies 'n' Thighs is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

8. Pies 'n' Thighs

8.7
166 S 4th St (at Driggs Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Fried Chicken Joint · Williamsburg · 553 tips and reviews

Maria R.Maria Real: Key lime pie yum city!

Lynn T.Lynn Truong: The spicy grapefruit juice is incredible as a mimosa alongside some amazing fried chicken with killer key lime pie for dessert.

Zoe L.Zoe Louis: The chicken and biscuits were amazing the pies were also good we tried key lime pie, cherry and s'mores

Little Cupcake Bakeshop is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

9. Little Cupcake Bakeshop

9.1
9102 3rd Ave (at 91st St), Brooklyn, NY
Cupcake Shop · Bay Ridge · 63 tips and reviews

Dee V.Dee Veras: Key Lime Pie Bar

KwanaKwana: Red Velvet, Dreaming Princess and Strawberry cupcakes are divine!

dawn h.dawn harris: Lucky charm treats rock!

DeKalb Market Hall is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

10. DeKalb Market Hall

8.8
445 Albee Sq, Brooklyn, NY
Food Court · Downtown Brooklyn · 110 tips and reviews

Jesse L.Jesse Lane: Great selection. Favorites are the Pierogi Boys, Hana Hand Pulled Noodles, and the Key Lime pie shop.

Erik Z.Erik Zuñiga: Make a stop at the beer spot they have outstanding beers.

Marizanne V.Marizanne Visser: The empanadas and churros at Dulcinea 😍😍😍

Red Hook Lobster Pound is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

11. Red Hook Lobster Pound

9.0
284 Van Brunt St (btwn Verona St & Visitation Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 171 tips and reviews

David B.David Brahler: Key lime pie is a great way to end the meal

TimTim: Maine lobster rolls excellent. Connecticut lobster roll also excellent. Your move

New York HabitatNew York Habitat: The freshest of fresh. This casual Red Hook spot has one of the best lobster rolls in the city. Get one with a bag of chips and the blueberry soda. Yum!

Jungle Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

12. Jungle Cafe

7.8
131 Greenpoint Ave (at Huron St), Brooklyn, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Greenpoint · 35 tips and reviews

Melissa P.Melissa Perez: The chefs special: vegan nachos!! I also tasted the tempeh ruben. I say go with the nachos it was full of flavor. Oh! And the key lime pie is to die for so mousy and delicious.

Clare R.Clare Ros: Excellent polenta, a tad spicy!

EaterEater: Go try Greenpoint's newest Vegetarian spot Jungle Cafe now serving Mexican, Polish, Chinese, and Indian fare in a cafeteria style setting. Read more.

Blossom Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

13. Blossom Ice Cream

7.1
196 Court St (Wycoff St), Brooklyn, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Boerum Hill · 18 tips and reviews

Blossom I.Blossom IceCream: key lime pie is the best

Brandon F.Brandon F.: I was born in a barn and had ever had rolled ice cream before. Madre de Dios this stuff is good. Friendly staff too. I recommend the Key Lime Pie.

Grace K.Grace Kwan: The first place I ever had rolled ice cream. It's super fun to watch them make the ice cream, and the results are delicious.

Maison May is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

14. Maison May

8.0
246 Dekalb Ave (at Vanderbilt Avenue), Brooklyn, NY
French Restaurant · Clinton Hill · 50 tips and reviews

Cecilia S.Cecilia Schiera: Great key lime pie with vanilla ice cream. The tilapia and mashed potatoes are good too.

Celestine M.Celestine Maddy: High styled pastries and healthy breakfast options. Beautiful space. Great for catching up with a friend

Mark E.Mark Egan: I wanted to slap myself In the face for not coming here only now in the 2ish years I've lived nearby.

Heavy Woods is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn.

15. Heavy Woods

8.4
50 Wyckoff Ave. (at Willoughby Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
Bar · Bushwick · 85 tips and reviews

Vanck Z.Vanck Zhu: Key lime pie is incredible.

James B.James B: Awesome coffee, AMAZINGLY southern comfort food. Go for the gumbo

Rebecca S.Rebecca Sutter: "Take, eat; this is my Biscuit which broken for you. Do this in remembrance of me." - Our lord and biscuit savior, 1 Cajuns 11:23-26