Shelsky's of Brooklyn is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

1. Shelsky's of Brooklyn

9.1
141 Court St (at Atlantic St), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Boerum Hill · 128 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: Russ & Daughters-style smoked fish and appetizing meets 2011 Brooklyn. All the smoked fish and bagel sandwiches are awesome, and the baked salmon salad would make your rebbi smile.

Real Cheap EatsReal Cheap Eats: "The baked salmon salad works really well with a warm, toasty bagel; in one bite, the combination is cool, warm, crunchy and soft. The salad tastes fresh and will satisfy any salmon lover." Read more.

NatNat: Peter knows his fish! A true connoisseur and a chef. They have the best smoked whitefish salad on the east coast. This place should not be missed!!!!

Frankel's Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

2. Frankel's Delicatessen

8.8
631 Manhattan Ave (at Bedford Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Jewish Restaurant · Greenpoint · 66 tips and reviews

Robert Tolar H.Robert Tolar Haining: I had whitefish salad on rye with French fries. Delicious!

Tabitha J.Tabitha Johnson: Get the whitefish salad!! So amazing.

Élise W.Élise Wyatt: White fish salad on pumpernickel bagel!

Acme Smoked Fish is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

3. Acme Smoked Fish

8.8
30 Gem St, Brooklyn, NY
Fish Market · Greenpoint · 31 tips and reviews

Amanda D.Amanda Dora: The white fish salad is divine!

NicolaNicola: Great spot to go and grab your smoked fish selection or fish salad on Fridays morning (8am-1pm) and bring it at home. Very local adventure. Lovely!

AJ M.AJ Mentaiko: Amazing salmon roe, pastrami salmon and whitefish salad.

Jus Juice is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

4. Jus Juice

8.2
1403 Nostrand Ave (Martense St & Linden Blvd), Brooklyn, NY
Juice Bar · Flatbush · 22 tips and reviews

Sandra A.Sandra A.: The salmon salad is everything! Delicious & very filling. The protein shake is definitely a good after workout choice.

Drew F.Drew Flowers: Salmon salads

Michelle B.Michelle Bolton: One of the best salmon burgers and salmon salads I've had. Everything is so fresh. I also go here for the Wheatgrass shots.

Bergen Bagels is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

5. Bergen Bagels

8.1
473 Bergen St (at Flatbush Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Prospect Heights · 102 tips and reviews

Jeremy V.Jeremy V: Great bagels. Get the whitefish salad on a garlic with red onions. That's how you do it.

Leah F.Leah FundraisingHelp: LOVE the whitefish salad - and I didn't even know I LIKED whitefish salad before I ate theirs.

Leah F.Leah FundraisingHelp: Smoked fish salad to die for

BKLYN Blend is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

6. BKLYN Blend

9.2
194 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Health Food Store · Bedford-Stuyvesant · 16 tips and reviews

Emma F.Emma Follender: Best made-to-order salmon salad I've ever had, and there's a pillow corner. Incredibly friendly staff gave me some smoothie samples to try while I waited. Ideal work spot.

Bohdan H.Bohdan Hnatkovskyy: Bagels are super special here. This place is amazing for morning coffee and breakfast.

Javier R.Javier Rueda: The place itself it calls you in. Nice interior and great to spend the morning there working etc. Great juices and healthy breakfast and lunch options plus very original ones.

Geido is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

7. Geido

8.8
331 Flatbush Ave (btw Park Place & Prospect Place), Brooklyn, NY
Japanese Restaurant · Prospect Heights · 80 tips and reviews

Kyle W.Kyle W: Get the super dragon roll. Miso soup and sashimi salad.

Jthekid3Jthekid3: Must have the Ceviche de Sashimi salad

7th.List7th.List: Savor: Sumo Maki (tuna, salmon, fish roe, avocado, egg, asparagus, cucumber); Dynamite Roll (tuna, eel, avocado, ginger flakes, crab); Geido Sushi Special for two Read more.

Highway Bagels is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

8. Highway Bagels

7.7
1923 Kings Hwy (Ocean Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Sheepshead Bay · 8 tips and reviews

Bruce S.Bruce Solomon: Fantastic Tuna Salad here.

Lucia D.Lucia Di: After trying several bagel shops, this is the best in the area. Seating area available. Nice staff.

Lucia D.Lucia Di: The very overpriced tip is incorrect. I found it to be very reasonable and cheaper than the others on the area. Whole grain bagel w lox spread $3.

Westville DUMBO is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

9. Westville DUMBO

8.8
81 Washington St (York St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · DUMBO · 30 tips and reviews

Kelsey✨Kelsey✨: The salmon salad is perfect and the menu also includes a variety of great vegetarian and vegan options.

David B.David Ban: Sleekest decor of all the Westvilles, including outdoor seating w/ happy hour in warmer months.

Dustyn W.Dustyn Winder: Super kid-friendly (kids' menu, crayons, high chairs) and great happy hour specials. Love getting a four vegetable platter. Beets w/ walnuts and goat cheese is a particular stand-out.

Bagel Boy is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

10. Bagel Boy

9.2
8002 3rd Ave (80th St), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Bay Ridge · 27 tips and reviews

Patricia Q.Patricia Quartana: Tuna salad on everything bagel toasted with lettuce oil and vingar

Dana L.Dana Lancaster: Wide selection of bagels and cream cheese; sandwiches are made perfectly; friendly, quick service. My favorite bagel shop in Bay Ridge! Rivals Park Slope's La Bagel Delight.

Thomas S.Thomas Scibilia: I'm all about the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese!

Paneantico is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

11. Paneantico

8.7
9124 3rd Ave (at 92nd St.), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Bay Ridge · 59 tips and reviews

Alison B.Alison Beth: Tuna salad is amazing here! The dressing is delish

Andrew C.Andrew C: Some of the best Italian sandwiches in Brooklyn. Get Mozzarella and Prosciutto on their bread!

LadyMissDiLadyMissDi: Get the # 9 sandwich on brick oven bread with chicken cutlet - the best!!

Mill Basin Bagel Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

12. Mill Basin Bagel Cafe

7.9
6319 Avenue N, Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Bergen Beach · 12 tips and reviews

Joyce C.Joyce C: Love the lox, tuna salad and the baked salmon. Expensive, but worth it. Always crowded, but line moves fast.

Catherine R.Catherine Ritorto: Great place for bagels and specialty coffees

Tricia S.Tricia Sheehan: Good bagels. Quick service.

Bagelsmith is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

13. Bagelsmith

8.2
566 Lorimer St (at Metropolitan Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · East Williamsburg · 107 tips and reviews

Bret J.Bret Johnson: White fish salad, capers, and swiss. Toasted garlic bagel. Go for it. Trust me.

Alex P.Alex Pyatetsky: For my keto folk, the tuna salad here is quite good (reminds me of WholeFoods). Besides bagels it's like a nicer bodega.

Cami R.Cami R: Their western omelet comes with toast and sautéed potatoes PLUS it includes a small coffee. Great for "brunch take out" if you order ahead and go pick up!

Stolovaya is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

14. Stolovaya

7.8
813 Avenue U (btwn 8th & 9th St), Brooklyn, NY
Russian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 27 tips and reviews

Maxim I.Maxim Ilin: Bitochki po selyanski and tuna salad are my favorites!!!

ChrystieChrystie: Authentic Homestyle Russian food. Get some vodka to shoot and some cherry compote. Start with the Siberian Pelmeni (dumplings) and a Cheburecki. The Beef Stroganoff is the BEST here. Kebabs are great.

Raisa B.Raisa Berger: This place is like coming home to mom's place after living by yourself for a decade. Excellent food, excellent atmosphere.

Fob Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Salad in Brooklyn.

15. Fob Restaurant

8.1
271 Smith St (Degraw and Sackett), Brooklyn, NY
Filipino Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 31 tips and reviews

Matej M.Matej Mavriček: The lemongrass punch was delicious, but the overnight adobo with thr garlic rice was fantastic. Thr flounder was very nice, not mind blowing. Tuna salad with Taro chips excellent.

Elaine L.Elaine Lin: Incredible pancakes (get the plain) on the brunch menu.. hands down the best in the neighborhood. All the bbqs are good.

Valentin G.Valentin Guerin: Nice outdoor, but service was very slow (even if the restaurant was empty) and food was just ok