Orlando M. • April 18, 2011Excellent pizza. Sauce is delicious, crust thin and perfectly crisp! Stop in for quick and friendly service...manja manja!
Michael V. • February 17, 2012There pizza has not been as good rather the pizzeria on Fort Hamilton Pkwy and 68th
Mike G. • October 4, 2013Best Italian dishes in the hood. Fresh Ingredients and Huge Portions. Always end up taking home another meal!
Jeffrey E. • November 4, 2012vodka sauce is awesome! try the vodka pizza of penne vodka. their heroes are also superb
Village Voice • August 15, 2014Totonno's sports the best fresh mozzarella of any pizzeria in town. That this cheese is a little soupy, making the pie damp, is fine with us. Just grab a fork!
Susan R. • March 22, 2015This is one of the best pizzerias to pop up in the neighborhood. They make a great heart shaped pie (by request) for special occasions with that special someone. Friendly staff.
Kevin C. • February 21, 2016Heroes, linguini and clam sauce, all the different slices are good. Try the stromboli slice
The Corcoran Group • May 1, 2011This old-school pizzeria has been around forever due to their pizzas with golden and lightly crispy crusts, tangy sauce and their famous white pizza.
Gordon • August 15, 2014Got takeout for a 12" pie, not your typical size slices, but just right for $7.50.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.