Myers of Keswick is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

1. Myers of Keswick

8.7
634 Hudson St (btwn Jane & Horatio), New York, NY
Food and Beverage Retail · West Village · 47 tips and reviews

Angel Hana A.Angel Hana A.: The quaint shop offers homemade pork pies, sausage rolls, chicken and mushroom pies, Their mince pies are quite delicious.

Heather T.Heather T: Awesome sausages and pork pies!

Jessica W.Jessica Wickham: Perfect if you want a little bit of British culture in your cupboard or for a snack. Fresh pies and pasties, Heinz, Robinsons and dandelion & burdock! Great during holidays, easter & Christmas treats

The Waverly Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

2. The Waverly Inn

8.8
16 Bank St (at Waverly Pl), New York, NY
American Restaurant · West Village · 131 tips and reviews

Douglas EllimanDouglas Elliman: A high-end restaurant offering a unique take on American home cooking. We love how the fireplace adds a cozy and comfortable feel. Go with friends, and be sure to order the Chicken Pot Pie!

Andrew F.Andrew Flicker: Chicken Pot Pie is awesome ! Grilled/roasted squid starter small but tasty. Well crafted drinks

Cihan E.Cihan Ergur: Biscuits, I could eat tens of them.. Chicken pot pie & fries is a must! Ask for a table near fire place and oh they're not allow you to instagram your meal, YES..!! 😝

Tea & Sympathy is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

3. Tea & Sympathy

7.7
108 Greenwich Ave (btwn 12th & 13th St), New York, NY
Tea Room · West Village · 136 tips and reviews

Holly W.Holly Wang: Things to try: chicken pot pie, treacle pudding, sparkling Ribena, strawberry cupcake, and afternoon tea for two!

amNewYorkamNewYork: Grab English tea for two – w/ sandwiches, scones, clotted cream and jam — or favorites like bangers and mash or shepherd’s pie in a setting cozy enough to please the most demanding English auntie.

Jeffrey N.Jeffrey Ng: Chicken and Vegetable Pie is amazing. DO IT!!

Gottino Enoteca Salumeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

4. Gottino Enoteca Salumeria

8.9
52 Greenwich Ave (at Perry St), New York, NY
Wine Bar · West Village · 106 tips and reviews

nantini r.nantini rauch: the rabbit pot pie, amazing crust & heavenly comfort food on a snowy night.

charles c.charles carrico: excellent wine bar - all Italian wines, all good choices - excellent cheeses - try the rabbit pot pie - friendly and attentive service -

James M.James McGrath: The crostini are to die for. The fig, goats cheese and honey one especially. Also make sure you check out their freshly made fritatas and pies, incredible.

Cowgirl is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

5. Cowgirl

7.7
519 Hudson St (at W 10th St), New York, NY
Tex-Mex Restaurant · West Village · 159 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: You haven’t lived until you’ve had the Frito Pie! We also enjoy the good strong drinks, the friendly service and the Chicken Fried Steak. One of our favorite themed restaurants in NYC.

Layla K.Layla Khoury-Hanold: Frito pie oh my!

Ashe B.Ashe Birt: The service here is great! I had a problem with my food and they were courteous and quick about solving it and gave us a discount without us asking. Truly classy. The Frito pie is also delicious!

Market Table is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

6. Market Table

8.0
54 Carmine St (Bedforf), New York, NY
American Restaurant · West Village · 145 tips and reviews

jennie v.jennie virzera: Lunch = Delicious. Gnocci, Seared Skate, Apple Pie - SO GOOD

Scott H.Scott Hueston: grilled sea bream with kohirabi, fennel & red grapefruit is sensational. quinoa hushpuppies w/ capers & lemon: superb. for dessert, get the apple pie with SOUR CREAM gelato - instantly devoured

Phil N.Phil Nom: Simple produce driven fare! Loved the chicken and apple pie

Magnolia Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

7. Magnolia Bakery

8.6
401 Bleecker St (at W 11th St), New York, NY
Bakery · West Village · 435 tips and reviews

Leigh F.Leigh Ferreira: the cupcakes are great, but I luv the pumpkin whoopie pie, sugar cookies & icebox cake. yum!

Frank R.Frank Rimalovski: My kids think this place is heaven. Icing is a little sweet for my taste, but cupcakes, cakes & pies are all pretty damn good. Constant long lines, but move pretty quickly. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.

Erika A.Erika Arrea: Banana pie! Mmmmm!

Left Bank is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

8. Left Bank

7.9
117 Perry St (at Greenwich St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · West Village · 48 tips and reviews

Spencer F.Spencer Fry: I like the pork chop and the chicken. Also try the maple pie.

Josh S.Josh Saletnik: Try the maple pie!

Robert Tolar H.Robert Tolar Haining: Great "new american" restaurant. The fish was great! The "maple syrup pie" was good – sort of like a denser chess pie.

Urban Vegan Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

9. Urban Vegan Kitchen

8.1
41 Carmine St, New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · West Village · 26 tips and reviews

Tru D.Tru Dy: The pumpkin pecan pie made me not miss the dairy at all. And I loved the coconut whipped cream. #vegan

VegetaurusVegetaurus: Had the macro bowl and pumpkin pie for dessert and ice cream! Lovely place

Pedro P.Pedro Pignatari: excellent food and people for a good price. ask for the tacos

Carry On Tea & Sympathy is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

10. Carry On Tea & Sympathy

7.8
Greenwich Av, New York, NY
Gourmet Store · West Village · 7 tips and reviews

Jessica W.Jessica Wickham: Perfect shop for an English treat from cupboard essentials to chocolate bars. Also great for seasonal treats like mince pies or Easter eggs

Michael M.Michael Muse: Amazing scones. The can't-miss order is scrambled eggs with cheese and beans on white toast. Branston pickle and cheese sandwich is also awesome.

Chrissy K.Chrissy K: They have a good list of teas, and you can also order a hot tea to go. Also lots of candies and snacks

Hudson Hound is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

11. Hudson Hound

8.4
575 Hudson St (btwn Bank St & W 11th St), New York, NY
Gastropub · West Village · 15 tips and reviews

John S.John S: Mac & Cheese. Shepard Pie. The Service

Giulio M.Giulio Mecocci: Burgers and shepherd pie

Pete M.Pete Marcus: Loved this place. Great pub and good fries too.

Wilfie & Nell is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

12. Wilfie & Nell

8.4
228 W 4th St (at 7th Ave.), New York, NY
Gastropub · West Village · 175 tips and reviews

Tom🐳 L.Tom🐳 Limongello: Get the Guiness Shepherds Pie or the Pea Soup w/Ham, or anything they pour into a crock pot.

Jessie G.Jessie Gonthier: Great food for a pub, esp shepards pie. Unfortunaltely consistenly full of douchebags who went to Nyu and now work in finance

Jason D.Jason Desmarais: Awesome place. Will definitely return. Great drinks, food, service. 5 stars.

Flex Mussels is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

13. Flex Mussels

154 W 13th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · West Village · 177 tips and reviews

Nicholas B.Nicholas Beck: As should always be the case after eating seafood, you should get the key lime "pie" for dessert.

Jannica R.Jannica Robertson: The South Pacific & the Parm Mussels are delicious. Leave room for the key lime pie parfait dessert.

Joanna N.Joanna Newman: If you don't get the key lime pie, I hate you

Buvette is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

14. Buvette

9.2
42 Grove St (btwn Bedford & Bleecker St), New York, NY
French Restaurant · West Village · 533 tips and reviews

Anna D.Anna D: Great cocktails and wine selection! Apple pie is a must 💙

Kathleen C.Kathleen Corless: Amazing atmosphere, great wine selection and coffee, I had the rabbit pot pie and it was outstanding!

Kristen M.Kristen Maguire: The lobster pot pie was incredible and perfect in every way

Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in the West Village, New York.

15. Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery

9.3
28 Greenwich Ave (Charles Street), New York, NY
Bakery · West Village · 62 tips and reviews

Jasmine K.Jasmine Kounang: Spinach & zataar hand pie and old fashioned donut are amazing. Probably the best old fashioned I’ve ever had. Cakey, but not too dense with a yummy glaze.

Victor C.Victor C: The finest selection of pastries and desserts and cakes and cookies in the city.

GothamistGothamist: The amazing Chocolate Explosion, has a crackling exterior, fudgie insides, and deep cocoa flavor. Read more.