1. Virgil's Real BBQ
7.9
152 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 6th Ave), New York, NY
BBQ Joint · Theater District · 273 tips and reviews
Janice Sullivan: The hush puppies with maple butter and Trainwreck Fries are to die for. The Carolina Pulled Pork is delicious too. I can't wait to go back.
Henrik Oscarsson: Classic southern style bbq. Simple but good. Try the pork ribs, or the brisket. They are finger-lickin' good. Good beer assortment too.
Yanin De Jesus: The best plate is their brisket. And I love their Maple Butter abd Biscuits. I pick only biscuits for my sides!
2. Toloache
8.5
251 W 50th St (at 8th Ave), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Theater District · 395 tips and reviews
Jeffrey: Dinner was great last night. Loved the Toloache Margaritas, the special Tuna Belly in crispy tacos, and the brisket tacos were a revelation!
Hunter Boyle: Whoa - short rib tacos are out of this world. Spicy guac is also a winner.
Ting: The taste is why this place is pricier than your usual Mexican fare. Both vegetarian paella de quinoa and Costilla de Res (braised beef short rib in molé sauce) were very good. Guacamole yums too!
4. Indian Accent
9.0
123 W 56th St, New York, NY
North Indian Restaurant · Theater District · 69 tips and reviews
Rewan Parti: This place is Michelin star worthy! Beautiful presentation and delicious food. Go for chefs tasting, order the pathar beef kebab, duck chettinad, sweet pick rib, dal ghost and butter chicken naan.
Zeba Siddiqi: Inventive indian cuisine! Pathar Beef, Duck chettinad , Sweet pickle rib are a must try! For veg options try House made paneer , Shiso leaf chaat . Do order butter chicken kulcha. Doda barfi dessert
Francesca Castelli: So good! The cocktails are pretty inventive and well done. Food was really good. The pickle ribs was probably the closest thing to meat candy i have ever had. Highly recommend the gosht!
6. Hard Rock Cafe
8.4
1501 Broadway (at W 43rd St), New York, NY
Theme Restaurant · Theater District · 603 tips and reviews
Jake Smith: Try the Mexican BBQ platter with pulled pork and pulled chicken.
Guillermo Tacoa: Ribs & Burgers The Best Food Ever..
Christian Dickmann: Get the hickory bbq bacon cheeseburger. And for sure get the hot fudge brownie. It's an insane portion of brownie, ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream and nuts. So good!
8. Bapcha
7.2
W 49th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Food Truck · Theater District · 12 tips and reviews
Shah: The BBQ chicken is delicious.
Urban Oyster: Bapcha literally translates as "rice car," the Korean word for food cart. To say thank you for your delicious bulgogi to owner John Lee in Korean, just say, "Kamsahamnida."
FoodtoEat: The Galbi Box makes a great lunch anyday! Order from Bapcha online at foodtoeat.com
10. The Halal Guys
8.6
W 53rd St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Halal Restaurant · Theater District · 891 tips and reviews
Sean M: Worth taking the trip from NJ on late drunken nights. chicken/lamb combo is good.use excessive white sauce w/ a little BBQ. you won't regret it. But you will if you accidentally put hot sauce instead.
David Azar: Its the best and biggest portion of Street cart anywhere. go combo with white and BBQ unless u like it spice then switch BBQ for hot sauce...
Aizen Sousuke: I love this classic food cart, delicious with the rice, bread, lamb and chicken, white sauce and BBQ...... And I never have to wait for lines!!!!! VIP
11. Junior's Restaurant
8.5
1626 Broadway (W 49th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 53 tips and reviews
Ronald Velten: Great pulled pork sandwich, but way too noisy!
Karla Santibnz: The pulled pork sandwich, the mac n’cheese and the plane cheese cake was good but not awesome
Greg Kastigar: Of course, the cheesecake. Don’t miss it if visiting NYC.
12. Aldo Sohm Wine Bar
8.5
151 W 51st St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Theater District · 60 tips and reviews
AmateurConcierge: The short rib skewers are so tender, but the merguez is tops. Get a 6 cheese flight and a glass of red and enjoy the quintessential midtown ambience.
Ina Li: Excellent ambiance, delicious snack selections (*short ribs skewers), and reasonably priced wine. Try the $20 flights. Perfect for dates and small gatherings
Rubén García: Great wine list, and nice apps to go with it. The rib eye skewer, the foie gras, and the cheese and charcuterie boards were some of the highlights
Kelsey✨: Pulled pork vindaloo is spicy & so good, especially with some garlic naan
D C: the biryani is delicious
Rewan Parti: One of the best fast food Indian in the city. Do order chicken tikka, black lentils and paneer tikka. The food is fresh and served hot. They have the option of biryani, dosa, fiesta and salad.
14. Gallaghers Steakhouse
8.8
228 W 52nd St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Theater District · 108 tips and reviews
New York Post: Forget the pricy Porterhouse, bone-in filet and rib-eye. At just $24 the chopped steak (a supple grind of rib-eye, chuck and short ribs) delivers magic its more expensive cousins don’t. Read more.
Norman Cox: Steak, short ribs..
James C: Amazing steak and the service was exceptional. Price is what a really good New York steakhouse is. However it is worth it. Need a reservation.
Sarah Hayden: Dee-licious brisket and reuben :)
Robert Neumann: Went in with a few friends from out of town, wanted to do something touristy. The singing waitstaff was as talented as always, and I was pleasantly surprised by how good my brisket sandwich was.
Tara Bree: Fun atmosphere. Generally there is a line wrapped around the corner, but we arrived at the right time. The staff sing songs from popular musicals. The pulled pork sandwich was delicious!