3. Caledonia Bar
8.7
1609 2nd Ave (btwn 83rd and 84th), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · Yorkville · 73 tips and reviews
J Lee: Massive single malt selection, cudos to Michael for curating it. And there is a William Wallace broadsword above the bar. Awesome
NY Waterway: This bar's Scottish heritage makes it stand out from the many nondescrcipt Irish-American bars that populate Manhattan. Whisky selection includes over fifty single malts and forty blended malts.
✰ David Mathison ✰: One of the best selections around. If you are overwhelmed from all the options (and you might be), ask the bartenders for recommendations - they are friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful,
4. Copper & Oak
9.0
157 Allen St (btw Stanton & Rivington), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · Lower East Side · 40 tips and reviews
Christopher Tai: Come here for single malt scotch whisky!
Christianna Hay: Wonderful friendly staff, with great recommendations. Impressive selection across single malts, Japanese varieties, as well as blends, armagnacs and cognacs
Ernesto Gutierrez: For any whiskey connoisseur, this is your Mecca. A breathtaking selection of whiskeys awaits. Try them all or just stop by for a few rounds.
6. Keens Steakhouse
9.1
72 W 36th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Koreatown · 482 tips and reviews
Eatocracy: In 1905, Lillie Langtry sued to be allowed access to the gents-only premises. Upon winning, she swept in and ordered the mutton chop. Follow her lead. Don't miss prime-rib hash and 200+ single malts.
Nikolaos: Single malts, the best steaks... I mean what else you can possibly ask for...
Dean Hanlon: For less than the price of the famous mutton (mutton!), treat yourself to the chopped salad, three slabs of thick cut bacon and a glass of Bruichladdich 10yr. Dinner of champions.
7. On the Rocks
8.3
696 10th Ave (btwn 48th & 49th St.), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 47 tips and reviews
Ben Baker: Balvenie..
Hector: Knowledgeable bartender on great selection of single malt scotch, whiskey, and bourbon. Small, cozy, intimate spot for great conversation.
Denis Sosnovtsev: Dark and intimate atmosphere, with a focus on the wall of whiskey. The ambience and whiskey selection are great, but you pay through the roof for 'em. Talking $17 a whiskey. 😬
9. Death & Co.
8.8
433 E 6th St (btwn 1st Ave & Ave A), New York, NY
Speakeasy · East Village · 394 tips and reviews
Carlo M: Myra Breckinridge (Laphroaig 10yr scotch, sugar cane sugar, lime juice, absinthe, fresh mint) on the Resurrection list is a must have!
Daniel Deluca: Eye of Torino is the best whiskey cocktail I have ever had!! Love Bowmore 12yo :D
Gary Toriello: "St. George & The Dragon"Red Breast 12 yr Irish Whisky, Laphroaig 10 yr Scotch, Punt e Mes Red Vermouth, Bénédictine DOM, Pernod Absinthe
10. Hudson Bar and Books
8.0
636 Hudson St (btwn Jane St & Horatio St), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · West Village · 64 tips and reviews
Alan Petrilli: If you are in the mood to splurge, get the Dalmore Cigar Malt, pricey at $40 a pour, but it's discontinued and a fantastic pair with a nice stick
Siddhaarth Jalan: A super selection of cigars and single malts...
Siddhaarth Jalan: Single malts
11. The Polo Bar
8.9
1 E 55th St (5th Avenue), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Midtown East · 65 tips and reviews
Gary Toriello: "Fred & Ginger" - Yamazaki Single Malt Whisky Zacapa Rum, Remy Martin Cognac, cinnamon
Julie Soscia: Reservations will definitely need to be made in advance, but you can enjoy a meal or cocktails at the bar. All the food is delightful, but the steak is a must!
Jason Rodriguez: Everything about this place is perfect. Polo Burger and an old fashioned are a must.
12. d.b.a.
8.0
41 1st Ave (btwn E 2nd & E 3rd St), New York, NY
Bar · East Village · 216 tips and reviews
Daniel Fisher: Have a beer, single malt, tequila, bourbon, or wine at this amazing establishment!
eric mortensen: Great single malt selection. Great beer selection. Not so great chance of getting any sort of service on even remotely busy nights.
Untappd: Amazing bar in the East Village. Great tap list and an outdoor enclosed area to enjoy your pint in the warmer months!
13. The Hamilton
8.4
998 Amsterdam Ave (109th and 110th), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · Upper West Side · 19 tips and reviews
Zlata Zubenko: Try the perfectly balanced Vieux Carre, rye & cognac cocktail. Great bar overall, with a focus on American whiskey
Christophe Jammet: Scotch eggs, whiskey, steak and eggs. Awesome mellow brunch.
Trevor Beckingham: Good selection of Whiskey and a very nice and knowledgeable bartender. Looking forward to going back soon!