2. Toloache
8.5
251 W 50th St (at 8th Ave), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Theater District · 395 tips and reviews
Jeffrey: Dinner was great last night. Loved the Toloache Margaritas, the special Tuna Belly in crispy tacos, and the brisket tacos were a revelation!
Erin O'Keefe: Probably the best tradition marg on the rocks with salt I've ever had.
Sean Naughton: The Cucumber/Jalapeño Margarita is Awesome! Not to spicy!
3. Arriba Arriba
8.0
762 9th Ave (at W 51st St.), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 162 tips and reviews
Daniel Eckenrode: EVERYTHING is Amazing!! Especially the Margaritas!! The staff is Super Cute, Friendly, and Fun!
andi Bass: As a Texan who is pretty picky when it comes to Mexican I must say this ranks in top 5 in NYC. Great margaritas, real salsa (!!!) and tasty fajitas.
GuySpy App: Try the margaritas, strong and big!
6. The Wayland
9.0
700 E 9th St (at Avenue C), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Alphabet City · 283 tips and reviews
Naomi Hyman: Best. We had every drink btwn the 3 of us; all amazing, ESP garden Marg. food also **: sausage bread and cheese on bread honey dessert
Anna Frenkel: Great weekday spot. Live jazz! All the signature cocktails are delicious (I especially love the garden variety marg) and the food is good too. Packed beyond belief and stoopid on the weekends.
Stan Bashmashnikov: Try the Garden Variety Margarita or Apple Pie Moonshine. Admire the exposed brick while sipping and smiling at your date.
7. Ofrenda
7.8
113 7th Ave S (at Christopher St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · West Village · 175 tips and reviews
Lisa Paravano: red guac, fish tacos, cucumber margs.. done & done.. love this place.. great happy hour.
Linds: Loved the unique guacamole (topped with nuts), the mushroom tacos (only comes with 2) and the cucumber margarita.
Chad Horner: awesome happy hour ($7 margaritas) and the regular menu is very agreeably-priced as well.
9. Maya
8.2
1191 1st Ave (btwn E 64th St & E 65th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Upper East Side · 148 tips and reviews
Becca: Try their new Tequilla Pavaneo .. it's awesome! Especially in a pineapple marg, yum :)
Kaitlyn Pezik: tasty margs, great guac.
Saleem: Great happy hour until 7pm, including $6 specialty margaritas and $6 glasses of wine. Extremely nice management and good ambiance is a winning combination
10. Agave
7.5
140 7th Ave S (between W 10th & Charles St.), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · West Village · 169 tips and reviews
Adam I: Best frozen margaritas in town, on the rocks are great too, $4.50 from 4-7 weekdays. Read more.
Glenna DeRoy: Great margaritas. Go for the grande.
Natasha Taylor: You do get a pretty great brunch deal: $24.95 for an entree and unlimited mimosas, bloody maries or frozen margaritas for 2 hours.
11. Tacuba
8.4
802 9th Ave (W. 53rd St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 102 tips and reviews
Hector: Get the carnitas, they are excellent. Amazing service. Delicious authentic cozy Mexican spot with great margaritas. Share the appetizers and tacos too.
Lynne Viera: octopus & chourizo tacos are top notch - served on housemade corn tortillas. micheladas and margaritas are fantastic.
Ernie Bello: The best Mexican I've had in the city. Tacos and ceviche were extremely special, the quesadilla was light and fresh, and the margaritas were fantastic.
12. Cowgirl
7.7
519 Hudson St (at W 10th St), New York, NY
Tex-Mex Restaurant · West Village · 159 tips and reviews
Foodie SL,UT: Grab some southern comfort food. Fried chicken, po-boys, mashed taters & delicious margaritas.
Marcus J: Half off margaritas from 3-6 are THE BEST! Strong and delicious. Take my word for it.
Jason Vincik: Amazingly tasty frozen margaritas. Nice and strong, not too tangy.
13. El Vez
7.9
259 Vesey St (North End Avenue), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Battery Park City · 158 tips and reviews
Chloe Karr: The blood orange margaritas are awesome and you won't be disappointed in the pork belly tacos (never thought watermelon pickles would go so well in a taco)
Dee💗Stacy: Even better then one in Philly and blood orange margarita is the best!!
Roxanna Flores: Delicious clAssic margarita (get the pitcher), nachos and fish tacos were very good.
14. La Esquina
8.5
114 Kenmare St (at Lafayette St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · SoHo · 724 tips and reviews
Eva Tomas: Be sure to have a reservation so you can go to the trendy restaurant downstairs! Great margaritas, great food, great ambience!
Jack Noble: Great queso fundido and margaritas.
A Del: Awesome secret basement scene, amazing tacos and margaritas
15. Añejo
8.0
668 10th Ave (at W 47th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 137 tips and reviews
Karen Kotchko: Anejo margarita's are great! Try the trio of guacamole. .. Really tasty.
Ivy: Añejo margarita super fresh, loved. Good selection & ambiance. Could use a light inside to see menu at night if you're not near a window lol pork tacos 👍 yes please!
Jinnie L: short rib tacos! yumyum~ :) very delicious margarita n guacamole trio - pineapple, mango, pomegranate, so good!! ♥