Crave Fishbar is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

1. Crave Fishbar

8.0
945 2nd Ave (at E 50th St.), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 103 tips and reviews

Pam B.Pam B.: Best Tuna Sandwich

jessica m. h.jessica m. hintermeister: Best Tuna Sandwich: flaky yellowfin tuna cooked confit style tossed in a lemony vinaigrette btwn slabs of toasty, house-baked focaccia & dressed w. arugula & fried artichokes (extra crunch) LUNCH ONLY

Nicole Y.Nicole Yale: NY Times: Best tuna sandwich in NYC

Eastwood is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

2. Eastwood

8.8
221 E Broadway (at Clinton St.), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Two Bridges · 45 tips and reviews

ChelseaChelsea: New York Magazine Cheap Eats issue says to get the Israeli scotch egg ($4) and either the fish & chips or fish sandwich for $12.

Nikki P.Nikki Palumbo: What to get: Israeli Scotch egg, $4; fish and chips, $12; fish sandwich, $12.

Milan V.Milan Vatovec: Fish sandwich out of this world

The Picnic Basket is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

3. The Picnic Basket

8.5
65 W 37th St (btwn 5th Ave & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Garment District · 93 tips and reviews

Michael M.Michael Milberger: The crunchy tuna sandwich changed my life.

Argelys O.Argelys Oriach: The Tunisian tuna sandwich is really good. Hummus and chips are good too

Nate L.Nate Linsky: This place is awesome. The crunchy tuna sandwich is without doubt the best tuna fish sandwich I’ve ever had. It almost feels incorrect to call it that.

Alice's Tea Cup is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

4. Alice's Tea Cup

8.4
102 W 73rd St (btwn Columbus & Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Tea Room · Upper West Side · 205 tips and reviews

Meghan-Sara K.Meghan-Sara Karre: The tuna sandwich will change your life! Try the chocolate chai! Be sure to save room for chocolate mousse!

Hermione M.Hermione Mu: Salmon sandwich is very good. Skip the berries scone, but chocolate scone is a delight!

Patricia W.Patricia Warner: Love the open salmon sandwich and the lemon tart!

Mary's Fish Camp is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

5. Mary's Fish Camp

8.5
64 Charles St (at W 4th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · West Village · 140 tips and reviews

Nathan C.Nathan Chessin: The Atlantic Cod sandwich was one of the best fish sandwiches I've ever had. It was off the hook! Perfect seasoning, great dressing and soft but crunchy bread. Brussel sprout salad is also a must.

Mike S.Mike Singleton: On your first visit, go ahead and get the lobster roll. Second visit I'd try the cod fish sandwich. Plan for it taking you a good hour to get through all the shoestring fries though.

Jasmine D.Jasmine D: Cod sandwich + fries

Miss Lily's & Melvin's Juice Box is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

6. Miss Lily's & Melvin's Juice Box

8.6
132 W Houston St (btwn Sullivan & MacDougal St), New York, NY
Caribbean Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 346 tips and reviews

Dom G.Dom Goodrum: Share the Jerk chicken roti and grilled fish sandwich. So good.

Engin C.Engin Cilasun: Try the fish sandwich!

Raquelle J.Raquelle Jessie: Awesomeee atmosphere! Get the fried fish sandwich on coco bread & ask for extra scotch bonnet pepper hot sauce on the side. Get the street grilled jerk corn on the side too!

Banh Mi Zon is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

7. Banh Mi Zon

8.1
443 E 6th St (1st Ave. & Ave. A), New York, NY
Vietnamese Restaurant · East Village · 85 tips and reviews

Banh Mi ZonBanh Mi Zon: WE'RE INTRODUCING A NEW TREAT: GRILLED CATFISH SANDWICH

Cassandra R.Cassandra Rommel: The catfish sandwich is excellent! Best bahn mi in the area. Everything is made fresh daily. They are very committed to not throwing food away so be warned, they run out of food near closing.

Robert C.Robert Campos: Catfish sandwich

Hillstone is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

8. Hillstone

9.0
378 Park Ave S (at E 27th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · NoMad · 265 tips and reviews

Jason T.Jason Tran: The George's Bank Fish Sandwich is the best thing on the menu! Pair it with cous cous and you will be in heaven!

Jason T.Jason Tran: George's Bank Fish Sandwich is the best!!!!

Patrick B.Patrick Baskin: Great spinach artichoke dip & fish sandwich!

Lobster Place is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

9. Lobster Place

9.1
75 9th Ave (btwn W 15th & W 16th St), New York, NY
Fish Market · Chelsea · 384 tips and reviews

Joel G.Joel Goldman: Get the smoked salmon sandwich, you'll be happy you did.

Felipe P.Felipe Pietri: smoked salmon sandwich is to me perfection!

Christopher D.Christopher Doyle: Try the grilled fish sandwich. The harissa and zataar make it so much better.

Bite is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

10. Bite

8.4
211 E 14th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Gramercy Park · 114 tips and reviews

Caroline C.Caroline Cruz Mo: delicious sandwiches..i had the exotic tuna sandwich with sundried tomato/basil mayo, and an aloe vera mango drink for just a buck more

Kj K.Kj Kramer: Exotic Tuna sandwich. Tuna with curry. Better than you'd think!

Gustavo G.Gustavo Grillo: Black forest ham panini, awesome and spicy

B Cup Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

11. B Cup Cafe

8.4
212 Avenue B (E 13th St), New York, NY
Coffee Shop · Alphabet City · 110 tips and reviews

Dan B.Dan Bedford: Get the tuna sandwich and dip it in the balsamic vinaigrette that comes with the salad. OM NOM NOM

Nikki W.Nikki Wegner: Tuna sandwich and sweets and coffee

Inna G.Inna G: Brie honey apple sandwich is amazing

babbalucci is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

12. babbalucci

8.7
331 Malcolm X Blvd (127th Street), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Central Harlem · 33 tips and reviews

Zayed K.Zayed Khan: The tuna panini here might be the best tuna sandwich I've tried anywhere. The whipped goat cheese really takes it to another level.

Malte L.Malte L.: Great pizza with fresh (!) ingredients. Friendly staff. A place you can also drop by later in the evening (after 22.00).

Harlem A.Harlem Ambassador: The joint is poppin' on a Monday pm that is saying something! While many will rave about that wood fired pizza, that is nothing compared to the shellfish dishes which are fresh and flavorful. A must!

Burger Heights is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

13. Burger Heights

8.5
177 Wadsworth Ave (btwn W 181st St. & W 182nd St.), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Fort George · 27 tips and reviews

Timothy S.Timothy Stevens: The new Riverside is a great fish sandwich.

Katie V.Katie VanLangen: The Amsterdam! And get it spicy, the hot peppers are excellent.

DanaDana: Love the wadsworth and cheese fries!!! Highly suggest you try this place....great gourmet burgers at affordable prices.

JOE & THE JUICE is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

14. JOE & THE JUICE

8.2
67 Spring Street (Between Crosby & Lafayette St), New York, NY
Juice Bar · SoHo · 103 tips and reviews

Brandon P.Brandon Perlman: Get a bodyguard juice and a spicy tuna sandwich! The best of Sweden is now in NYC!

Maisoon M.Maisoon Ma: The juices are fabulous can’t remember which one I chose but try one of their signatures, the tuna sandwich was yum

Ray P.Ray Perea Kuri: Great ambiance! Good music, good juices, good paninis.

JOE & THE JUICE is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish Sandwiches in New York City.

15. JOE & THE JUICE

7.8
67 Wall Street (at Pearl St), New York, NY
Juice Bar · Financial District · 17 tips and reviews

Jenny L.Jenny L: My favorite in the neighborhood. Coffee is surprisingly good in addition to juice & smoothie. I liked the spicy tuna sandwich too. A lot of space to bring your laptop and readings plus free wifi.

Lynn🍍Lynn🍍: Spicy tuna sandwich😋

Neelu R.Neelu Ravi: Great place to sip on your coffee or a healthy smoothie and work on your computer as long as you want. Avacado toast here is my favorite. I love the one located in SoHo while Wall Street one isn’t bad