One of our ten best Manhattan bars-The bartender will whittle you a perfectly spherical ice ball for your Old Fashioned right before your eyes. A jazz trio keeps the place hopping.
Excellent old fashioned and sazerac. Nice candlelit speakeasy
Very enjoyable Old Fashioned and the best Sazerac I've had outside New Orleans. Helpful bartenders and a nice setting.
Get there early, put name/number in, promptly come back when you are called that your table is ready. Get a craft cocktail (the waiter had great suggestions), get the Mission Chinese hot dog. Perfect.
Try the old fashioned with bacon infused bourbon and maple syrup from Momofuku.
Still hard to get in, still amazing. Bacon old fashioned is fantastic. Bartenders can make any drink on request. Though it got touristy the space is intimate, dark and sexy.
Pucker up, this place is all about the bitters. Highly recommend the Bittermen's Gin & Tonic and Eight Amaro Sazerac.
Best old fashioned in the city
Great hole in the wall for bitters based cocktails (manhattan and negronis). Real east village gem
Small plates of truffle fries, pork belly and goat cheese profiteroles; with fantastically crafted cocktails. Try the Black Magic, it's unique!
This place is expensive, but it's my absolute favorite fancy cocktail bar in the city. Everything is great. Everything.
Another awesome craft cocktail bar. There are so many in NY, but you can't go wrong with Death & Co.
Beef tartare rank high on NYC's must try: bone marrow poppers come a close second. Great mixologists! fan of weekday nights; wknds are a serious shitshow
Cool bar atmosphere! Very tasty craft cocktails.
Very cool vibe. Great drinks + mixologists. Ordered the bacon wrapped lamb shanks with a side of sautéed kale- absolutely delightful!
Best speakeasy in this city. Tell the mixologist what you're feeling and he'll create the best concoction of your life. Tiny place so go on a Sunday night to get in without a wait.
Amazing mixology drinks I can't even recommend one they are all so good!
Amazing cocktails! Staff is extremely attentive and nice. One of the best mixology bars in the city, by far
Properly made old fashioned is always reliable here, along with a handful of well crafted cocktails.
Best Manhattan in Manhattan.
It's called "The Rum House," but you can't go wrong with the Elijah Craig Manhattan.
EaterNY calls the Pygmy Gimlet one of New York's best spring cocktails
Try the pygmy gimlet for something fruity or the bees knees for something unique. You'll need a password for prohibition wed when they have a different menu (hint: check twitter)
Awesome and fun mixology bar/lounge just a little random as far as location goes.
Amber old fashioned - best old fashioned I've ever had, hands down.
The De La Louisiane is a sazerac incognito. Great place to enjoy an Old Fashioned with close conversations.
This speakeasy knows how to set the mood. Very classy, very sexy, excellent mixologists. 🍸
Incredible classic cocktails in Harlem. Top Mixology, cracked ice, outre concoctions, intimate, amazing.
This Harlem Speakeasy has a rich historical background dating back to the Prohibition Era and has an extensive menu of uniquely crafted cocktails. Try The Long Pink Cadillac - it's amazing!
By far the best Old Fashion cocktail in NY...but only on Tuesday & made by Erick!
Satisfy your interest in the art of Mixology at this art deco lounge. End your work day with a perfectly concocted Manhattan or ask the bartender for a suggestion.
Fun! Dark & Stormy is good, the mint julep will get you good.
Best Old Fashioned in the city
Dead Rabbit is a must if you're a fan of craft cocktails!
Craft cocktail menu is on point. I have yet to try a dish other than oysters which were grade A++ and I'm super snotty when it comes to my oysters (I admit it). Gets packed so plan to wait on wknds.
Amazing craft cocktails, delicious food and rad atmosphere - especially in the parlor.
Love the blood orange sour and the pimms cup!!
Larceny bourbon is fantastic. 92 proof wheated bourbon. Their old fashions are amazing!
Pairings perfection here: Scotch egg w Old Fashioned. Custom Blackberry Sidecar w Chocolate hazelnut dessert. Done.
Looks fancy, but a really great place to get drunk. Love the Manhattans - three is enough for anybody. Well, maybe four...
Bail gimlet is amazing. This is the original mixology bar!!!
Basil gimlet for the win!! Such good drinks here! Definitely worth a try!
Perfect place for a late dinner and night of dancing! Ask for the Sapphire-Seventy Five or the Emerald Gimlet, two of my favorites!
Super loud with house music. Cool pawn shop facade/decor leads u back into a stunning speakeasy. Packed with people! Delish tapas and desserts and craft cocktails.
One of the best fancy date spots downtown. Unusual and well crafted cocktails and shareable plates.
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA