4. Cilantro
7.1
485 Columbus Ave (btw 83rd & 84th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Upper West Side · 56 tips and reviews
Phanessa: Steak Fajitas are tender and juicy, only $12 on Monday nights! Cash only for the special so be prepared.
ᴡ Arcus: Fajita Monday is wonderful. Everything here is delicious, even the chips. Ask for the garlic'y green hot sauce. Also, ask for the red hot sauce. Delicious and flavorful but soooo nose-running spicy.
Ozgun Zor: The best fajitas in da city! My dish came little late once and they didn't charge. But remember to tip :) they're kind as well.
5. Canyon Road
7.7
1470 1st Ave (btwn 76th & 77th St.), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Upper East Side · 29 tips and reviews
Amanda Albergo: Sunday night spot: Blue cheese nachos, fajitas, blood orange marg.
Derek Wittenberg: Fajitas are very dependable, and the spinach and mushroom enchilada was excellent.
Brett Fromme: A favorite tex-mex spot. Potent Margaritas! High noise level. I like the chicken enchiladas and the fajitas. Wimpy salsa with the chips.
6. Hell's Kitchen
8.1
754 9th Ave (51st St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 26 tips and reviews
Alice Nam: Delicious fajitas, guac, and sols!
Kelsey✨: This place is FREEZING, but the fajitas are good way to warm up 🔥
Indira Fernandez: Everything is amazing the fajitas super tasty best shrimp I’ve had. Margaritas are good great ambiance
7. Baby Bo's Cantina
7.8
627 2nd Ave (at E 34th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Murray Hill · 118 tips and reviews
Kishin Manglani: This place does the basics very well: enchiladas, burritos, tacos, fajitas, margaritas.
Naomi Piercey: One of the most affordable, coolest, tastiest Mexican joints in Manhattan. Usually not too crowded. Fajitas are enough to share!
Francis Udler: Great find. Small place with amazing food and interesting menu.steak fajitas were delicious.
Michael Muse: This place is LEGIT. Get the fish tacos and a Michelada if you havent tried them here, they're both particularly good. Also, the fajitas & enchiladas are great. Everything's great.
Swen Graham: If you're considering the fajitas, I've done a side by side comparison of chicken & steak. The chicken was the unequivocal winner.
Michelle Connochie: Really tasty fajitas. Huge portions with very friendly staff members in a relaxed setting. Definitely worth a visit!
13. El Parador
8.1
325 E 34th St (btwn 1st Ave & Tunnel Entrance St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Murray Hill · 91 tips and reviews
The Corcoran Group: Sit at the bar and enjoy a delicious margarita while dining on a mix of chicken and beef fajitas. Finish your meal with the Mexican Fried Ice Cream.
Sarah Henn: The chicken fajitas were superb!
Kara Dawson: Favorite margarita in the city! Strongly recommend their guac, shrimp quesadillas, chicken wings (not on the menu!), and taco tray. Just do it.
14. Santa Fe
7.2
73 W 71st St (at Columbus Ave), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 30 tips and reviews
Mei Yee Mak: $10 Fajita every Monday night!!
Michael V: $10 fajita Mondays. Great deal if you can avoid drinking oodles of good margaritas.
Emt Suj: Enchiladas Suisses are very tasty. Steak fajitas are great, as was the chicken and the shrimp. Good sizesd portions, good value, pleasant decour and staff. I'll be back.