1. The Waverly Inn
8.7
16 Bank St (at Waverly Pl), New York, NY
American Restaurant · West Village · 131 tips and reviews
Douglas Elliman: A high-end restaurant offering a unique take on American home cooking. We love how the fireplace adds a cozy and comfortable feel. Go with friends, and be sure to order the Chicken Pot Pie!
Andrew Flicker: Chicken Pot Pie is awesome ! Grilled/roasted squid starter small but tasty. Well crafted drinks
Cihan Ergur: Biscuits, I could eat tens of them.. Chicken pot pie & fries is a must! Ask for a table near fire place and oh they're not allow you to instagram your meal, YES..!! 😝
2. Penelope
8.0
159 Lexington Ave (at E 30th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Rose Hill · 424 tips and reviews
Nat Harward: Chicken Pot Pie: "Forget the brunch rush at this friendly neighborhood spot and go straight for the main attraction: a creamy, dreamy, chicken pot pie of your very own." Read more.
Morgan Von Steen: Forget the brunch rush at this friendly neighborhood spot and go straight for the main attraction: a creamy, dreamy, chicken pot pie of your very own. - Buzzfeed
Ro J: Their regular lunch menu is quite pricey. Their chicken pot pie was absolute perfection but also cost $19. Loved their service and their cute vintage-y decor!
3. The Smith
8.5
55 3rd Ave (btwn E 10th & E 11th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · East Village · 517 tips and reviews
Mallory Zumbach: You can't go wrong with the mac and cheese or the chicken pot pie-- great comfort food! I'm partial to their brussel sprouts as a side, and Friday's special of the day, the lobster roll.
Joey J: Great burger, Gnocchi, Kale Salad, Burrata, Chicken Pot Pie, Bibbity-Bop :). Everything is great.
Niketa Patel: Chicken pot pie & banana bread pudding were delicious!
4. Friend of a Farmer
8.1
77 Irving Pl (btwn E 18th & E 19th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Gramercy Park · 347 tips and reviews
Robert Gaal: A good selection of beers, corn bread for the table, chicken pot pie, a killer fish of the day always. Nuff said.
Misha M: Chicken Pot Pie is a warm party in your belly...
Stan Bashmashnikov: Super cozy, warm place. Great service. Feels like you're dining at a bed and breakfast in Maine. The Chicken Pot Pie is a must.
6. The Dead Rabbit
9.3
30 Water St (btwn Broad St & Coenties Slip), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Financial District · 487 tips and reviews
Lori Luo: Opt to sit in the upstairs Parlor for a chance to try a drink from their extensive cocktail menu and order several bites, such as the Fries or Chicken Pot Pie, as well.
Amy Mixa: The lamb shepherd's pie is WAY smaller than the chicken pot pie...go with the chicken!!!!!!
Paul Morini: Tough place to get in. But worth the hassle. The stirred cocktails are based on old fashions and are delicious. I had the chicken pot pie, wonderful and my guest had the shepherds pie also super.
8. The Smith
8.8
956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 362 tips and reviews
Ryan Platner: WOW! Oysters on the half shell, streamed mussels, and chicken pot pie! I said "DAMN"!!!!!
Jessica Stark: Shareable snacks/apps for a slightly larger group: Hot Potato Chips & Beer Battered String Beans. Dinner: Chicken Pot Pie. Was amazing but LARGE--be prepared to share or take some home!
Tatjana Tesic: Good food, fair prices. Try the chicken pot pie. Place a bit loud though. Check the unisex restrooms! Watch your steps when looking at the signage.
9. Fraunces Tavern
8.7
54 Pearl St (at Broad St), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · Financial District · 194 tips and reviews
@juliefogg Fogg: Chicken Pot Pie has been on the menu since George Washington ate here. It was the most savory dish I've enjoyed. Make sure you have 1.5 hours for this place. Hard to get in & out, fast.
Michael Natale: Grab a seat at the pub. There's tons of whiskeys and a great selection of beer. Try the famous chicken pot pie or the gouda mac and cheese with bacon.
Wayne Bennett: Great Fish n Chips, , Salmon Chowder and Chicken Pot pie. Tried a 2 oz shot of Knobs Creek limited Bourbon. I sat on toilet that George Washington used. History wow!
10. Earl's Beer & Cheese
8.9
1259 Park Ave (btwn E 97th & E 98th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · East Harlem · 169 tips and reviews
Edward Manson: Great beers and heart warming chicken pot pie. If you're in the upper East Side/beginning of Harlem it's a must visit.
Greg Levitt: All three dishes we ordered were great: chicken pot pie, huevos rancheros, and earl salad (with pork belly!)
Avram Levi: The chicken pot pie was insane says my wife and my mother in law!
12. Ear Inn
8.5
326 Spring St (btwn Greenwich & West), New York, NY
Pub · Hudson Square · 149 tips and reviews
Simon M: Best try the chicken pot pie
christian svanes kolding: never thought i'd be praising the chicken pot pie but here i am, praising the pie. delicate with an echo of curry in the sauce and a perfectly flaky shell. sit outside in the fading afternoon light.
Christina Walkinshaw: Landmark drinking? Don’t mind if I do🍻 A classic vibe, great bartenders and a chicken pot pie😋
13. White Oak Tavern
8.1
21 Waverly Place (Greene St.) (Greene St), New York, NY
Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 51 tips and reviews
Waley Chen: Chicken pot pie was awesome!
Debby Butlien: Friendly staff but a chicken pot pie without chicken? They made me a new one but still had only 3 pieces. And the crust was incredibly salty. Skip this dish.
Joseph Fisher: Friendliest staff who will remember you every time. Fantastic food with some creative flare (lamb nachos, for example). And half price bottles of wine on Sundays! Love this place.
James John (Jay) Cudney IV: Chicken Pot Pie is so hot, you can't taste or eat it! Took 15 min to cool down and all the crusty bread turned to mush. Taste was ok but otherwise a miss.
Ben Kay: A gem to visit. So firstly yes it's a cosy affair. Tables super close together (let's call it intimate). Staff equally intimate in a laid back, cooking for friends style. Incredible burger. Best ever?
Mark Heyert: Excellent tater tots, crab cakes, beet salad, and the bartenders are sweet and funny.