Casey Rubber Stamp is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

1. Casey Rubber Stamp

9.3
322 E 11th St (2nd Ave & 1st Ave), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · East Village · 14 tips and reviews

Brian O.Brian Orce: Great place. Nice, eccentric staff. Def go here for any rubber-stamp needs. Support cool NYC businesses like this one.

Enia T.Enia Titova: I'm so glad I found Casey. His store is what makes NYC worth the high rent, and the bed bugs, and the shitty weather.

Alexis T.Alexis Tirado: This store is why I love the East Village. Locally-owned with a crazy array of cool stamps. The ornery owner, Casey, has the best stories of old school NYC too!

Artist & Craftsman Supply is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

2. Artist & Craftsman Supply

8.7
2108 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd (btwn W 125th St & W 126th St), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Central Harlem · 3 tips and reviews

NiaNia: Great for all mediums of art from jewelry making to sculpting. Small selection of yarns.

Harlem A.Harlem Ambassador: Where in the world has this art supply behemoth been all our lives? FINALLY, a selection that is so vast, Andy Warhol would have given it a thumbs up. Graffiti artists will dig the spray selections.

Mia P.Mia Pamela: I really liked this place from the moment I walked in. Helpful staff and one of the only local art suppliers. Now, Im there every Sunday, hosting events 3-5pm.

La Mano Pottery is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

3. La Mano Pottery

8.8
110 W 26th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave.), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Chelsea · 3 tips and reviews

ChevroletChevrolet: Spark Your Senses with the Chevy Spark! Perfect your sense of touch with a pottery class at La Mano Pottery.

Rudy V.Rudy Valenta: Learn how to throw a bowl, cup, and plate. Matthew is the best teacher to learn from with a good sense of humor

Jessica S.Jessica Soe: Wheel session

Knitty City is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

4. Knitty City

8.8
208 W 79th St (btwn Broadway & Amsterdam), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Upper West Side · 12 tips and reviews

Tamara E.Tamara Espinal: I love this yarn store! They have one of the best selections I've seen in NYC.

Jess T.Jess Tonn: Check out the sale yarn in the back. Great deals for small projects.

Ed C.Ed Costello: Had a proper domestic partner's chair for the non-knitting spouse.

M&J Trimming is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

5. M&J Trimming

8.4
1008 Avenue of the Americas (btw 37th & 38th St.), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Garment District · 24 tips and reviews

Marc C.Marc Canter: Amazing place for anything to do with sewing, costumes, decorations, buttons, tassels, crystals, ribbons, feathers. All the stuff that Michael's doesn't have! Read more.

Lucky MagazineLucky Magazine: Get lost inside the enormous MJ Trimming store and buy fun ribbons, buttons and trinkets to accessorize your own sneaks, belt, headbands etc.

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Winner of Best Place to Pretend You're Preparing for Project Runway in the Village Voice 2011 Best Of issue! Not just buttons here.

Blick Art Materials is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

6. Blick Art Materials

8.3
650 Avenue of the Americas (20th Street), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Flatiron District · 21 tips and reviews

SheenaSheena: Unlike all the halloween stores in the city weeks before halloween, not crowded in the least! You don't event have to wait in line to get in and push through masses of people to check out!

Allen W.Allen Wan: Amazing and very knowledgeable staff. Great variety in there spray paint and acrylic paint

CakoCako: Amazing!!!! All types of canvas, markers wowwww 👍👍👍👍👍

Painting Lounge is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

7. Painting Lounge

8.3
39 W 14th St Ste 401 (btwn 5th and 6th Ave.), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Union Square · 8 tips and reviews

Casey A.Casey Anderson: Friendly teacher and fun experience!

Peyton H.Peyton Hawkins: Soooo fun!!!

Avery G.Avery Green: All you have to do is bring your bottle of wine they have bottle openers and cups and the teacher is patient and makes anyone look good lol

Mood Designer Fabrics is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

8. Mood Designer Fabrics

8.6
225 W 37th St Fl 3 (btwn 7th & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Garment District · 57 tips and reviews

NetsirkNetsirk: As much as MOOD is supposedly top notch because of fashion school and that TV show, you can find better deals around the area. BUT if you need everything in one location, you can find it in here!

hapticianhaptician: A total shit-show: go if you must, but use the fire stairs to exit unless you want to wait 15 minutes for a 3-floor elevator trip.

Jeffrey B.Jeffrey Baughman: Swatch is a Boston Terrier.

Blick Art Materials is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

9. Blick Art Materials

8.2
1-5 Bond St (btwn Lafayette & Broadway), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · NoHo · 61 tips and reviews

Lesley K.Lesley K: This Blick is the best one in the city. IMHO. Best variety & well stocked. One of best art supply stores overall too!

Adam G.Adam Geiger: Be prepared to wait a long time to check out. Cashiers move glacially.

Village VoiceVillage Voice: The Village Voice voted this Best Art Supply Store in our Best Of New York Poll!

Paper Source is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

10. Paper Source

8.1
344 W 14th St, New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Chelsea · 3 tips and reviews

Emily Y.Emily Yeager: Helpful & pleasant employees 🙂

SusanaSusana: I have spent way too much time here just looking at all their products. Large variety of stationary and seasonal decorations. Decent option for when you’re in a last minute gift-buying pinch.

Michelle W.Michelle Wiles: Better cards than papyrus

Tierra is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

11. Tierra

8.2
65 Spring St, New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · SoHo · 6 tips and reviews

DiabloDiablo: This is a really great spot to find one-of-a-kind jewelry. Everything is organically made and beautifully presented in this tiny shop. Also, the person who works there is super nice!

@BigAppleScoop@BigAppleScoop: If you aren't looking, you won't find this wonderful little surprise in NoLita. Bright and fun handmade jewelry.

PhanessaPhanessa: Everything is handcrafted in the Canary Islands. Beautiful and unique.

The Ink Pad is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

12. The Ink Pad

8.0
37 7th Ave (at W 13th St), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · West Village · 5 tips and reviews

Jason B.Jason Baughman-Oprică: One of my favorite shops in NYC. Great stationary and the largest selection of ink stamps and ink pads I’ve seen. Great place. 🖋

Lino D.Lino Di Maio: Rubber stamps everywhere. Crafting paradise.

Jaime S.Jaime Scatena: All sorts of stamps & craft supplies!

Make Meaning is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

13. Make Meaning

7.9
329 Columbus Ave (Between 75th and 76th Street), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Upper West Side · 7 tips and reviews

Florann E.Florann Estiler: Sign up for their classes. Great experience! Also, they have one week camps geared towards a different topic like dinosaurs and countries. Excellent for the kids.

Michael O.Michael Oh: Nice arts and crafts store for the kids!

Christopher F.Christopher Fillhart: Make sure to tip your Aces and Party Captains. They work hard to make the experiences great!

niconeco zakkaya is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

14. niconeco zakkaya

7.6
263 E 10th St, New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · East Village · 1 tip

Ian C.Ian Chee: Cute East Village Japanese stationary and hand-crafted gift shop. They ship worldwide.

The Feather Place New York City is one of The 15 Best Arts and Crafts Stores in New York City.

15. The Feather Place New York City

7.7
40 W 38th St Fl 3 (Between 5th & 6th Ave.), New York, NY
Arts and Crafts Store · Garment District · 4 tips and reviews

Penny and MaryPenny and Mary: Wedding has you antsy? Attend our knowledgeable wedding week for more tips and tricks! Read more.

For the MakersFor the Makers: It. just. sells. feathers. They got what you need if you need feathers. Individual, boas, vests (might have one) and feather tape.

The Feather PlaceThe Feather Place: Shop wholesale with your Sellers Permit or Sales Tax ID!