2. Bayona
8.6
430 Dauphine St (btwn St. Louis and Conti), New Orleans, LA
New American Restaurant · French Quarter · 57 tips and reviews
Trisha Wood: The peanut butter duck was to die for.
Gloria Chin: try the smoked dush cashew peanut butter and pepper jelly sandwich, honey lavendar ice cream, garlic soup & sweetbreads
TripExpert: A tip from our expert reviewer, Fodors: "A legendary favorite at lunch is the sandwich of smoked duck, cashew peanut butter, and pepper jelly." -On TripExpert Read more.
4. Pêche
9.3
800 Magazine St (Julia), New Orleans, LA
Seafood Restaurant · Lower Garden District · 204 tips and reviews
Juan Geldres: There's no banana in the chocolate peanut butter banana pie.
Lears Fool: Peanut butter banana pie FTW
Kika G: Try to maximize what you can taste from the menu because ALL of it is amazing. Pounded shrimp + noodles, crawfish bisque, and swordfish + farro w. peanut vinagarette, are keepers. Don't miss the pie!
5. Le Pavillon Hotel
8.0
833 Poydras St, New Orleans, LA
Hotel · Central Business District · 56 tips and reviews
Randy Bernsen: Great location, great vibe. Pool deck is nice and the peanut butter and jelly late night sandwiches! Oh. Food/buffet ,,,'n'awlins all the way.
The Leading Hotels of the World: Le Pavillon Hotel serves peanut butter and jelly sandwiches every evening in their lobby! Read more.
Chad Tovar: Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are super good!!! Look for them at10pm
6. Cochon Butcher
9.4
930 Tchoupitoulas St (at Andrew Higgins St), New Orleans, LA
Sandwich Spot · Lower Garden District · 585 tips and reviews
Mike Chau: Try the Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - With candied spicy peanuts. One of the best peanut butter things I've eaten.
Ken: The Elvis king cake is filled with peanut butter, banana and house-cured bacon and topped with marshmallow and traditional Mardi Gras decoration. A small pink pig replaces the baby. @Gambit
Mike Winston: A meat-lover's paradise. Love everything at this place, but don't miss the Fried Alligator, Fried Boudin, Rabbit & Dumplings, and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie. Read about it on WinstonWanders below!! Read more.
8. Restaurant R'evolution
9.0
777 Bienville St, New Orleans, LA
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · French Quarter · 81 tips and reviews
Pete Dumont: Incredible food, service. Great ambiance. LOVED this place! Try the homemade peanut butter ice cream.
Kevin Lilly: HANDS DOWN THE BEST RESTAURANT IN NOLA... Get the Filet, Crab Beignets and the Peanut Butter Ice Cream.. Thank me later
Alma Alling: This place was amazing. Excellent food and service. They have a table that faces the kitchen that I recommend you sit at. The wine menu is on an iPad and this place comes with little surprises. :-)
Christin "X1" L: Excellent Pralines - original, chocolate, peanut butter, sweet potato and more.
Rozanne Michaels: Best pralines! Best variety! Made fresh!!!
Ferne Kilcollum: Tried the top 5 praline shops per Yelp and yes, these are the best.
11. Creole Creamery
8.4
6260 Vicksburg St, New Orleans, LA
Ice Cream Parlor · Lakeview · 15 tips and reviews
James Welch: My family loves this place. Try a Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae. Amazing!
Geoffrey Gauchet: I cna't say I've ever had a bad flavor. When they have it, get the salted caramel. Also the chocolate, chicory, and caramel is good too. Read more.
Cody Yocom: Enjoyed the King Cake flavor during Mardis Gras season.
14. Ralph's On The Park
8.7
900 City Park Avenue, New Orleans, LA
Southern Food Restaurant · City Park · 31 tips and reviews
Gambit New Orleans: Peanut Butter Indulgences: try a sweet terrine of peanut butter ice cream, peanut praline and chocolate. -Gambit's Five in 5
Peggy Gartin: Good things for brunch: Lobster & Tasso Eggs Benedict, Barbecue Shrimp & Cream Cheese Grits, Bananas Foster Martini.
Gambit New Orleans: Crazy for crabmeat? Crab is made into a Napoleon with couscous, roasted corn and salsa verde - "Gambit's Five in 5" Read more.
Jennifer Edwards: They have the best pralines! Peanut butter and chocolate were my personal favorites.
Sampada Patel: Best beignets ever! Had the praline beignets this morning which were light and flaky with an intense caramel flavor. In contrast, Cafe du Monde’s are bready and dense. I will be back!
Nicole Cheramie: This famous bakery lays claim to New Orleans famous praline dessert. Get praline beignets for a rich, sweet treat or savory beignets stuffed with crab or bbq chicken. Open Tuesday through Saturday.