I have fished with many captains and crew...by far the gold standard is Fishing Headquarters. Capt. Rod is an outstanding Captain (gets you on the fish!) and his crew is always top notch.
Octopus appetizer is a must! Served with grapes, cherry tomate, nuts... spectacular! The cuscus served with the salmon is also one of a kind. Great terrace. Best dinner in Fort Lauderdale!
Truffled potato au gratin is a must. Kobe filet is also a great option and if you like seafood, the ceviche is worth trying for an appetizer