Olga's Kafe is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

1. Olga's Kafe

7.8
99 Summer St, Boston, MA
Café · Downtown Boston · 9 tips and reviews

Sam H.Sam Hooper: The peanut butter cup iced is the best around. I highly recommend this place!

Terence C.Terence Chan: Hidden gem with lots of delicious coffee flavors! My favorite is snickerdoodle

Daniel T.Daniel Tewfik: Perfect if you love Mary Lous or similar sweet iced coffee joint.

Blackbird Doughnuts is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

2. Blackbird Doughnuts

8.5
492 Tremont St, Boston, MA
Donut Shop · South End · 54 tips and reviews

Kate B.Kate Blanchard: Amazing doughnuts, so many cool flavors! The best I've had: dark chocolate raspberry, peanut butter cup, lemon poppy

Liam N.Liam Nee: Best of Boston 2016: Doughnuts 🍩 :: Varieties like cookies and cream, “everything” bagel, and sesame sriracha; head baker Anna Roine’s golden base is more pillowy pastry than fried dough.

Daniel T.Daniel Tewfik: Blackberry Lavender was good. Sesame Sriracha was less so. Ask to try their mini donuts, they might just give one for free.

Fiore Italian Bakery is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

3. Fiore Italian Bakery

7.7
55 South St (Custer St), Jamaica Plain, MA
Bakery · 42 tips and reviews

EricaErica: Vanilla Florentines are not to be missed, also try peanut butter cup cookies.

Alexis T.Alexis Troso: This place is awesome. The vegan spinach and onion scone was delicious and not at dry. The Italian Maki sandwich is unbeatable. Yum! I wish places like this existed near me.

Emily P.Emily Powers: Muffins are gooood

Thornton's Fenway Grille is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

4. Thornton's Fenway Grille

7.7
100 Peterborough St (at Kilmarnock St), Boston, MA
American Restaurant · Fenway - Kenmore - Audubon Circle - Longwood · 36 tips and reviews

Mike A.Mike A.: Great atmosphere. Had the Texas Toast special and it was delicious!!

Andrew M.Andrew Meggison: Great brunch and great location near Fenway Park

Stephanie S.Stephanie Stein: Perfect place for an easy brunch or grabbing a beer to watch a game! The outside tables are glorious.

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

5. The Cheesecake Factory

8.3
115 Huntington Ave Ste 181 (at Belvidere St), Boston, MA
American Restaurant · Prudential - St. Botolph · 174 tips and reviews

ChanLing B.ChanLing Beswick: Tried the mango key lime cake, cannot taste the mango. But the key lime portion is really tasty. Check out their chicken samosa app

Tarik C.Tarik Celik: Strawberry cheseecake

Anton K.Anton Kotenko: If you'll ever be in Boston, Cheesecake Factory is a first place to go if you really want to eat. Any of them. Huge tasty portions. Any salad, pasta or burger. All great. But huge. No ads.

Boston Burger Company is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

6. Boston Burger Company

8.3
1100 Boylston St (btwn Hemenway & Massachusetts Ave.), Boston, MA
Burger Joint · Fenway - Kenmore - Audubon Circle - Longwood · 101 tips and reviews

Food NetworkFood Network: One of the most outrageous and comforting burgers Guy has come across, this all beef patty is topped with a generous helping of homemade four cheese mac and cheese...and bacon Read more.

Simon K.Simon Katz: Lol idk get a burger and then cry yourself to sleep or something

Matt G.Matt G: Give a nod to Thanksgiving and order The Pilgrim. It won't disappoint. @BostonBurgerCo

Coppersmith is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

7. Coppersmith

40 W 3rd St (btwn A & B), Boston, MA
American Restaurant · D Street - West Broadway · 23 tips and reviews

PatriciaPatricia: Meal highlights: pumpkin soup (delicious) and the burger: toasty buttered bun, juicy meat, and a reasonable size so you can gobble down the entire thing without gastric distress.

nicola f.nicola forani: Very nice a cosy place. We had great chicken with a nice a spicy dressing + very nice calamari. Great service and very people.

Caroline D.Caroline Dickey: Cool industrial vibes. I stopped in for a weekday lunch and enjoyed the chill reggae music. Cool rooftop upstairs too. Fish tacos were super crispy & delicious + the Mexican street corn was AMAZING.

Cranberry Cafe is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

8. Cranberry Cafe

7.3
704 E Broadway, South Boston, MA
Café · 12 tips and reviews

Shannon D.Shannon Dempsey: Breakfast sandwiches are great, coffee is solid. Marissa and the staff are friendly and helpful. Cute cafe!

Jill H.Jill Huber: Don't come here in a hurry. Cramped inside. Good food though.

Cory L.Cory Lehey: I've been here twice. And they've messed up my order 3 times. Do the math. Coffee is good though.

J.P. Licks Mission Hill is one of The 9 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Boston.

9. J.P. Licks Mission Hill

7.2
1618 Tremont St (at Huntington Ave), Boston, MA
Ice Cream Parlor · Mission Hill · 25 tips and reviews

Sarah C.Sarah C: Great seasonal flavors and some are gluten-free

BostonTweetBostonTweet: Every night after 10pm the JP LIcks in Brigham Circle goes BOGO - buy one ice cream (cone, dish, pint, whatever) and get another for free until midnight.

SGA B.SGA Boston: Best ice cream in Boston.