Get a noah's ark for a sample of everything. Lobster roll is TO DIE FOR but the shrimp is a good substitute if you're on a budget. Always go for full-size or you'll just leave wishing you ordered more
Order the Taste of Maine: perfectly portioned for one person, you get to sample the shrimp roll, crab roll, and lobster roll...and be transported to Maine
Lobster rolls are some of the best in NYC. Portions are somewhat small, so opt for an app!
Had the lobster bisque with the lobster roll, was in heaven. The Maine root sodas are damn tasty too!
Lobster roll and bread bowl are amazing
Lobster roll and clam chowder were so good. Blueberry soda was delish too (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.
I'd vote for the fish taco's as well. The lobster roll is very good, but too mayonnaisey for my wife. And the lobster knuckles are fun and tasty if you are skilled at removal.
Order this: East Coast oysters, lobster roll, whole fish of the day, hot-fudge sundae Read more.
The best lobster rolls ever! And the cole slaw was good, has capers and not too saucy. Worth waiting in line for this place!
Very happy with this place. 20.00 per meal is a home run. Burger was very good...but..I must say. Lobster roll is the way to go. Potentially more lobster in it than u will get ordering the lobster.
Everything is $20. Lobster roll is great, 1.5 pound lobster is best value.
Great concept: 3 items only, burger lobster lobster roll. $20 does the trick. Great service.
Great seafood selection and good for a snack - fresh oysters, solid lobster roll. Good caviar selection. Sushi is nondescript - not the draw.
Pro: the lobster in the lobster roll is fresh & you can tell. Con: the place is always packed, eating comfortable won't be an option. You can get it in a lunch box that's also good!
Expensive but delicious. Lobster rolls are great and so are the oysters. Avoid the madhouse of Chelsea Market during lunch though.
The oyster and leek soup is fantastic, as are their lobster rolls, made with just the right amount of mayo on a buttery side-split bun.
Oysters, pistols on horseback & Connecticut style lobster roll
Excellent shrimp and mushroom toast and lobster roll. Also open later than rest of Chelsea market which is nice!
Awesome (and large) lobster roll, great staff!
Try the lobster roll - Great texture, very #fresh with a bit of #spice
Lobster roll, shisito peppers, fried green tomatoes, bloody mary's = amazeballs
West Coast oysters, Old Bay chips, ceviche and lobster roll were all incredible.
lobster roll is fresh and delicious, but obvious choice here are the oysters
Summer menu is loaded with treats: Heirloom Tomato & Watermelon Salad, Sea Scallops with Succotash + Soft Shell Crab Rolls. Plus... Oysters.
Great happy hour. Don't miss the burger or lobster roll (when in season).
Try the Lure lobster club. Homemade lobster salad is infused with crumbled bacon and juicy sliced tomatoes for a bit of texture and a ton of flavor. A tasty contender in our 2012 Lobster Roll Rumble: Read more.
We had a lot of appetizers. Fried oysters, dragon roll, lobster roll, baked clams, octopus salad. All stupendous. Seriously!!!
possibly my overall fave sushi spot in the city. i always get the honoo (spicy crab gunkan & spicy scallop roll - *INHALE*) n make whoever i'm w/get the sashimi deluxe platter. ;D
Love their salad, spicy tuna roll, spicy crab (w/o shiso), & blue crab california. Ginger ice cream is heaven. Green tea is excellent. Best sushi in NYC hands down.
Even with a great selection to choose from I still stick to the spicy blue crab roll and house salad with watercress, avocado, carrots, and ginger dressing, can't beat it!
Some of the best Asian food I've had in NYC. Try the big eye tuna tartare, red snapper ceviche tacos, sesame shrimp roll, and softshell crab roll. Accompany with the jalapeño margarita. Life changing.
Big eye tuna tart, sesame crusted shrimp roll, jalapeño scallop roll, crispy tuna rice
You must order the tuna tarts. They are insanely good. Also recommend the scallop roll, the oysters (special), and the crispy rice with tuna.
Lobster roll and fish tacos! Delicious!! Can't wait to go back!
Great fish tacos and lobster rolls, and nice rosé sangria. Cruise is timed just right so you don't feel trapped at sea. Def recommend!
No wait on wkday. Svc, drinks, & food were good. Lobster rolls, Medium shrimp & Jonah crab claws are fresh & must-try's! Oysters-Malpeque & Wellfleet-only ok. Free Hudson River 1/3-loop boat ride.
Get the lobster roll, it's a great roll and comes with fries!
Dog friendly place to stop for a bite; don't forget to get ur pooch a hot dog! Also u eat lobster roll meal yum yum!
lobster roll, sangria, and a view of the hudson
The Blue Crab roll is amazing!
Toro roll and blue crab rolls are out of this world. Eat it as soon as it's placed in front of you so it doesn't get soggy!
The lobster roll and the crab roll YUM
Love the slider sampler if you can't make up your mind... Lobster roll, fried clams, crab cakes. Can't go wrong
Go for their happy hr lobster roll special and drink! Two thumbs up to their friendly wait staffs.
Delicious salads, relaxing ans pretty atmosphere, and the looks of the lobster rolls with fries...yuuuuum. getting that next time. A bit of the east end right in nyc.
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA