The Pumpkin Pie was still warm! Delicious! 😍 Their coffee is really good too! I will always pop in when in NY! This is a cute little pie shop! 🎃
Great selection of fresh cake and cheesecakes for $1.99 - Wish I had found the Pumpkin pie cheesecake sooner!
Seduce your date with the Trophy Wife or delight her sweet tooth with Mz. Lilley's Pumpkin Pie Martini. Read more.
Seasonal cranberry chutney mix-in is awesome! Today's Pumpkin Pie custard has too much spice for my taste...
Great selection of tea and spices. High quality stuff at very reasonable prices. $2 - $4 per oz of most teas.
In addition to an extensive tea list, this place is a foodie's dream. They had every spice that you could think of and even some that I had never heard of. The owner was pleasant and knowledgeable. Read more.