The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

1. The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory

8.5
65 Bayard St (btwn Elizabeth & Mott St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Chinatown · 450 tips and reviews

Tricia D.Tricia Dietz: Best ice cream in New York! flavors you dont get everyday.. My favorite is greentea but around fall the pumpkin pie is to die for; zen butter and ginger are great to try too.

HayleyHayley: Pumpkin pie ice cream! Happy holiday in a cup.

Veronica Y.Veronica Y: Lychee, almond cookie & pumpkin pie are all delicious

Little Pie Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

2. Little Pie Company

8.6
424 W 43rd St (btwn 9th & 10th Ave), New York, NY
Pie Shop · Hell's Kitchen · 101 tips and reviews

Sarah K.Sarah K.: The Pumpkin Pie was still warm! Delicious! 😍 Their coffee is really good too! I will always pop in when in NY! This is a cute little pie shop! 🎃

Nidhi K.Nidhi Kay: Great pumpkin pie and Mississippi mud pie, also appreciate how very organized they are during holidays

Leonardo U.Leonardo Ueda: Best Cheesecake MY Style and Hot Pot Chicken Pie!

Whole Foods Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

3. Whole Foods Market

8.6
808 Columbus Ave (at W 97th St), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Upper West Side · 139 tips and reviews

Patrick O.Patrick OShaughnessey: Try the vegan pumpkin pie.

Sameepa S.Sameepa Shetty: Go for their holiday food menu samples now. Great pumpkin pie!!

Datrianna M.Datrianna Meeks: Love this place! They have such an awesome drink selection! Definitely try the samples they offer, you just might find your new favorite item!

Petee's Pie Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

4. Petee's Pie Company

9.0
61 Delancey St (btwn Allen & Eldridge St), New York, NY
Pie Shop · Lower East Side · 112 tips and reviews

Carol L.Carol Lee: $5 for the smallest slice of pumpkin pie. Even worse...it wasn't good. Maybe other pies are better...but won't be going back. So disappointed.....

Nidhi K.Nidhi Kay: Pumpkin pie ❤️, this place smells like home

Philip L.Philip Luu: Almond chess and maple walnut goodness

16 Handles is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

5. 16 Handles

8.3
1569 2nd Ave (btwn E 81st & E 82nd St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Yorkville · 60 tips and reviews

MarissaMarissa: Pumpkin pie flavor (seasonal) tastes like the real thing!

BrittBritt: lil britt special: 50/50 vanilla/peanut butter froyo, lots of kitkat pieces, generous helpings of marshmallow and peanut butter sauces

Sexy L.Sexy LF: Allow me to rave about the salted caramel froyo and the rainbow cookie topping! Not together tho.

Morton Williams is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

6. Morton Williams

7.9
140 W 57th St (6th and 7th Avenue), New York, NY
Supermarket · Theater District · 24 tips and reviews

Tom B.Tom Burns: Great selection of fresh cake and cheesecakes for $1.99 - Wish I had found the Pumpkin pie cheesecake sooner!

Lauren B.Lauren B.: Store is incredibly organized and well-stocked! Some things are a little pricey but great store overall!

MatthewMatthew: This clean supermarket, located near the Carnegie Hall, offers 2 floors of grocery items and a small cold/hot buffet ($7/lb). Head upstairs (open until 11 pm) for decent seatings with free WiFi.

Emack and Bolio's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

7. Emack and Bolio's Ice Cream

8.6
389 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W. 78th St & W. 79th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Upper West Side · 53 tips and reviews

Cynthia L.Cynthia Li: I'll take Pumpkin pie ice cream over a pumpkin spice latte any day.

Danielle L.Danielle Leach: Cookie Monster ice cream (Oreos and cookie dough) in a Fruity Pebbles cone!

Katherine C.Katherine Cheng: Mint chocolate chip with oreo cookies. Yum.

The Grey Dog - Union Square is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

8. The Grey Dog - Union Square

8.5
90 University Pl (btwn E 11th & E 12th St), New York, NY
Café · Greenwich Village · 327 tips and reviews

heathr g.heathr gold: only order the pumpkin pie if you feel lie eating an enormous amount of it.

ritu a.ritu a: Get the pumpkin pie this fall. It's perfection.

Public House W.Public House Wine: Great salads, chill vibe, and killer chai.

Coolhaus Ice Cream Truck is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

9. Coolhaus Ice Cream Truck

8.2
New York, NY
Food Truck · Upper West Side · 72 tips and reviews

Kelsey L.Kelsey Lee: In the fall, get the pumpkin pie ice cream with pieces of real pie crust, sandwiched between the hot cake cookies - unbelievable.

Terri R.Terri R: So good! Flapjack/hot cake cookie with chicken and waffles ice cream!

Gilt CityGilt City: Every Coolhaus sandwich comes in an edible wrapper that can be custom-printed with safe-to-eat ink. And if that's not cool enough: flavors include mango saffron, peanut butter miso and mango saffron.

Shake Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

10. Shake Shack

9.1
Madison Square Park (Madison Ave & E 23rd St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · NoMad · 1236 tips and reviews

Amy L.Amy Lan: Portabello burger. Fries. Pumpkin pie frozen custard.

{Savored}{Savored}: Must get the pumpkin pie custard!!!

✨#IamRomdelacrème✨✨#IamRomdelacrème✨: My favorite Shake Shack location. Love having my Shack Stack burger with Fries and of course the Concrete. Try Pumpkin Pie Oh My when available.

The Crosby Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

11. The Crosby Bar

8.1
79 Crosby St, New York, NY
Hotel Bar · SoHo · 60 tips and reviews

BoozeMenusBoozeMenus: Seduce your date with the Trophy Wife or delight her sweet tooth with Mz. Lilley's Pumpkin Pie Martini. Read more.

CarolCarol: Vibrant and quirky art. The food and drinks were fantastic and the service was impeccable! Salmon is good. Getting to the bathroom downstairs is a journey. They have high tea!

Jason L.Jason Liszka: This is a @naveen kind of place. If your cheekbones are as glorious as his, you should go here.

Union Square Greenmarket is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

12. Union Square Greenmarket

9.3
Union Sq W (btwn E 14th & E 17th St), New York, NY
Farmers Market · Union Square · 411 tips and reviews

Lou S.Lou Sagar: check the stand near 17th street walk-up for the best pumpkin pies..I tasted them..bring one home to Momfor the holiday..or eat it late yourself

Daniel H.Daniel Hakimi: Fresh Baguettes, cider, cider donuts.

Food NetworkFood Network: I get all my produce at the Union Square Green Market in NYC. – Chef Anne Thornton, Dessert First

Shake Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

13. Shake Shack

8.8
691 8th Ave (at W 44th St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 855 tips and reviews

Janiejaner G.Janiejaner Grenier: Seasonal cranberry chutney mix-in is awesome! Today's Pumpkin Pie custard has too much spice for my taste...

Thalia K.Thalia K: Try the Pumpkin Pie Frozen Custard Concrete (fruit dessert) - I liked this concrete the best of all the ones I've tried here. Too bad it's only available during the holidays.

Khalil i.Khalil ibitefood: A good burger for a great price . Great job on the bun

Billy's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

14. Billy's Bakery

7.6
75 Franklin St (btwn Church & Broadway), New York, NY
Bakery · Tribeca · 60 tips and reviews

Jon L.Jon Lombardo: Get the Pumpkin Pie. Peanut Butter pie also amazing as well.

Yvonne D.Yvonne Diaz: Banana cake, banana pudding, snickerdoodles are yum

Gilt CityGilt City: Rachel Zoe must have had one of these banana cupcakes before she coined her signature phrase. Don't forget to take home their new baking mixes—you never know when the cravings will hit.

Sullivan Street Tea & Spice Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in New York City.

15. Sullivan Street Tea & Spice Company

8.9
208 Sullivan St (Bleecker), New York, NY
Gourmet Store · Greenwich Village · 19 tips and reviews

Jason G.Jason Gelman: Great selection of tea and spices. High quality stuff at very reasonable prices. $2 - $4 per oz of most teas.

Tea For Me PleaseTea For Me Please: In addition to an extensive tea list, this place is a foodie's dream. They had every spice that you could think of and even some that I had never heard of. The owner was pleasant and knowledgeable. Read more.

СусикСусик: Raw blueberry is very very tasty!