Squire's Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

1. Squire's Diner

7.3
80 Beekman St (Pearl St), New York, NY
Diner · Financial District · 32 tips and reviews

Haley G.Haley Greenwald-Gonella: The lemon meringue pie is amazing!!!

David S.David Solimano: Delicious breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a very comfortable dining room.

Mike N.Mike N.: One of the better diners in the NY area. Excellent prices and great service! The food.... It's from a diner, so it's awesome!

Fairway Market is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

2. Fairway Market

8.0
2127 Broadway (btwn W 74th & 75th St), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Upper West Side · 127 tips and reviews

Charles W.Charles Wilson: Try the lemon meringue pie, the awesome peach & blueberry cobbler!

Will J.Will Johnson: favorite grocery store in the city! you can find any and every coffee you could imagine here and cheap!

Scott S.Scott Stone: Go at off hours.

Theater Row is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

3. Theater Row

7.8
410 W 42nd St (btw 9th & 10th), New York, NY
Theater · Hell's Kitchen · 13 tips and reviews

Pat D.Pat Dwyer: Great space! Comfy seat rows w/legroom and good site lines.

Brian B.Brian Butler: Marvelous wonderettes

Cameron G.Cameron Gidari: I love that they support small and independent theatre, but I wish they had better AC. It was sweltering in the 4th-floor theater.

The Dutch is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

4. The Dutch

8.6
131 Sullivan St (at Prince St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · SoHo · 457 tips and reviews

Adrienne P.Adrienne Petrino: The best lemon meringue pie of my life!

Gillian B.Gillian BenAry: chef is Andrew Carmellini. Totally packed, so reservations are essential. Killer wine list, great raw bar, fantastic food and stellar people watching. A good place to feel the energy of NY. Open late

Time Out New YorkTime Out New York: Try the little oyster sandwiches. Sesame-speckled buns each cradle one fat, crispy mollusk, iceberg lettuce and a smear of pickled okra sauce. They’re one of our #100best dishes and drinks of 2011. Read more.

Mansion Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

5. Mansion Restaurant

8.1
1634 York Ave, New York, NY
Diner · Yorkville · 65 tips and reviews

LaurenLauren: Best diner on the UES. Solid staples: eggs, home fries, wraps, etc. Great service & staff, too.

Ruben B.Ruben Brosbe: The York Ave is without a doubt the best item on a very solid menu

Anna O.Anna Osgoodby: One of my favorite diners around the UES. The staff is great, the menu selection can't be beat and the food is delicious!

Spaghetti Incident is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

6. Spaghetti Incident

7.7
231 Eldridge St (btwn Houston St & Stanton St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lower East Side · 48 tips and reviews

DinaDina: Homemade spaghetti, budino caramel pudding for desert

LaurenLauren: Rec'd: whole-wheat-spaghetti dressed w/ pistachio pesto and zucchini; bucatini all’ ­amatriciana. via New York Magazine/Grub Street | The 30 Best (New) Cheap Eats in New York [July 12, 2015]

BonBon: Spaghetti Bolognese was there exact meaty red sauce one would want. Kale pesto, don't do it. Kale is not for pesto. Artichoke arancini were great although not too choke-y. Great windowfront table.

Square Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

7. Square Diner

7.6
33 Leonard St (at Varick St), New York, NY
Diner · Tribeca · 56 tips and reviews

John M.John McCrory: Probably my favorite diner in the city. The burgers are charbroiled. Great with a thick chocolate shake.

Corey C.Corey Crago: It's a diner; it's cheap, it's good, and it's in New York. There aren't enough places like this left.

Max R.Max Rodriguez: Comfort food...popular with locals and blue collar types.

Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

8. Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner

8.1
548 3rd Ave (at 36th St), New York, NY
Jewish Restaurant · Murray Hill · 96 tips and reviews

Fay S.Fay Shapiro: Best service. Best bagels. Best lox.

Creighton D.Creighton DeSimone: Pastrami sandwich is fantastic here. Worth checking out.

Real Cheap EatsReal Cheap Eats: Try the Souper Soup. "Sitting in the heady chicken broth, which demands no salt, are a hearty beef kreplach, noodles and a gigantic matzoh ball that straddles the line between floater and sinker." Read more.

Don't Tell Mama is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

9. Don't Tell Mama

7.7
343 W 46th St (btwn 8th & 9th Ave), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 61 tips and reviews

KarenKaren: A piano bar. Grab a beer and enjoy!

Juan C.Juan Carrillo: There's a 2 drink minimum with every visitor. That's why they have no cover.

Juan V.Juan Vallejo: THE best place to sing in NYC!!!!

Murray Hill Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

10. Murray Hill Diner

7.5
222 Lexington Ave (at 33rd St), New York, NY
Diner · Rose Hill · 50 tips and reviews

Nick H.Nick Harris: Possibly the best and cleanest diner in the area

Nick H.Nick H: Great breakfast wrap options.

Katie L.Katie Lynn: So CLEAN!!!! try the Belgian Waffles, eggs and ham!

Washington Square Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

11. Washington Square Diner

7.1
150 W 4th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Diner · West Village · 46 tips and reviews

HashtagNYUHashtagNYU: For breakfast or coffee, this is JSex's favorite!

jon a.jon accarrino: they are open 24/7

Lenny G.Lenny Gallo: This place is a nice reasonably priced diner. I would recommend if you're looking for a casual dine with good service.

St. Tropez Wine Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

12. St. Tropez Wine Bar

7.1
194 Spring St, New York, NY
Wine Bar · SoHo · 7 tips and reviews

Amanda L.Amanda L: The Feuilleté is incredible. Strong champagne list. Breezy, fun vibes. I love both locations, but the Soho spot is my favorite.

Benjy W.Benjy Weinberger: Surprisingly good food for what seems like a tourist trap. The burrata was a standout.

Shohini G.Shohini Gupta: Great rose and charcuterie, truffle Mac and cheese

Milk Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Lemon Meringue Pie in New York City.

13. Milk Bar

7.8
251 E 13th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · East Village · 711 tips and reviews

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Lemon Meringue Pie - Pistachio, lemon curd

Jenn Z.Jenn Zhang: Compost Cookie + Crack Pie + Cereal Milk Soft Serve w. Corn Flakes + Birthday Cake truffles and it goes on and on and on and on

Madelyne D.Madelyne Dolandolan: Two words: Crack. Pie.