Horman's Best Pickles is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

1. Horman's Best Pickles

7.8
6th Ave & Carmine St (at 6th Ave.), Manhattan, NY
Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Barry H.Barry Hott: Try the horseradish and the honey mustard!

Felix G.Felix Grushevsky: Truly great pickles! From old classics to new "fusion" varieties for every palates

Connie S.Connie S: Gotta go for the horseradish pickles

Garden of Eden Marketplace is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

2. Garden of Eden Marketplace

7.9
7 E 14th St (btwn Broadway & 5th Ave), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Union Square · 47 tips and reviews

Josh D.Josh Dubin: The deli here has THE BEST honey mustard ever. Thick, sweet and spicy. Indescribably delicious.

Sammy A.Sammy Alkan: The following sections has a diverse selection and something for everyone: cold cuts, cheese, bakery (including bread)

mikaaa🌟 s.mikaaa🌟 shikiiii: 50% off of salad bar & hot bar everyday after 7:30pm

12 Chairs is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

3. 12 Chairs

8.8
56 Macdougal St (btwn W Houston & Prince St), New York, NY
Middle Eastern Restaurant · SoHo · 144 tips and reviews

BeccaBecca: Surprisingly well-priced for the area. Schnitzel was delicious, and their homemade honey mustard dressing is excellent and can be purchased by the bottle.

GothamistGothamist: Their menu includes all sorts of comfort foods for the breakfast hours, including french toast, omelettes and, of course, their version of Shakshuka ($12). Read more.

Walter B.Walter Blaurock: Don't fear; they have more than 12 chairs.

Chirping Chicken is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

4. Chirping Chicken

6.9
355 Amsterdam Ave (at W 77th St), New York, NY
Comfort Food Restaurant · Upper West Side · 85 tips and reviews

Melissa N.Melissa Neumann: Absolutely delish. I highly recommend the chicken finger, French fries, and an extra helping of their honey mustard!

Will H.Will Harahan: I love ordering chicken fingers with honey mustard here.

Joe O.Joe Ortiz: Far none one of the best chicken joints in the city. Great that they added a salad to my meal which was a surprise! Got crowded at times though, so off-peak hours is the best times.

Hyatt Place New York City / Times Square is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

5. Hyatt Place New York City / Times Square

8.4
350 W 39th St, New York, NY
Hotel · Garment District · 1 tip

Manuel A.Manuel Avila: Muy buena opción!

Sticky's Finger Joint is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

6. Sticky's Finger Joint

7.9
484 3rd Ave (at 33rd St), New York, NY
Fried Chicken Joint · Rose Hill · 62 tips and reviews

SiettahSiettah: Go for the chicken poppers instead of the fingers! The sauces are delicious but I didn't enjoy the honey mustard. Tasted more like straight yellow mustard.

Vanessa R.Vanessa Riley: I have tried the honey BBQ club and the Buffalo Balsamic Blue on the signature style menu and both were amazing. If u want something a spicy then the blue is the way to go.

Garett P.Garett Press: Get the bites instead of the fingers and as many dipping sauces as you can get your hands on. See attached pic.

Molly's Shebeen is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

7. Molly's Shebeen

7.8
287 3rd Ave (btwn E 22nd & 23rd St.), New York, NY
Irish Pub · Gramercy Park · 128 tips and reviews

Gordon M.Gordon Mei: Chicken fingers + honey mustard = crazy delish. Ask about the seasonal beer.

Christopher V.Christopher Vano: Best irish pub in the city. Amazing onion rings and mozzarella sticks.

The New York TimesThe New York Times: There are days when the only proper response to life is bangers and mash, pints of Guinness and sawdust on the floor. Here’s your man.

Westside Market Place is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

8. Westside Market Place

8.1
790 11th Ave (55th St.), New York, NY
Deli · Hell's Kitchen · No tips or reviews
Sammy's Gourmet is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

9. Sammy's Gourmet

8.1
1404 Madison Ave, New York, NY
Deli · East Harlem · 2 tips and reviews

Lane R.Lane Rettig: Ask for Sammy. He's a cool dude and he makes a mean shawarma.

Carla M.Carla Moscoso: Toasted sesame bagel & cappuccino...best way to start the grind.

Clinton Gourmet Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

10. Clinton Gourmet Market

8.0
648 10th Ave (46th), New York, NY
Deli · Hell's Kitchen · 7 tips and reviews

Matthew F.Matthew Ferguson: Great selection of hard ciders.

Alex R.Alex Robertson: Good selection of beers and the guy clearly knew his stuff—picked out, without thinking about it, a 10% ABV IPA when I asked for same—very impressive

JohnJohn: The ice coffee is good but it is light on the caffeine

The Grey Dog - Nolita is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

11. The Grey Dog - Nolita

8.2
244 Mulberry St (btwn Spring & Prince St), New York, NY
Café · NoLita · 300 tips and reviews

Michael K.Michael Karnjanaprakorn: Can't go wrong with the Grey Dog Club w/ honey mustard.

Leah W.Leah W.: Perfect for a trendy but casual night out. Gives you a little country feel in a big city. Tip: get the cobb salad with green goddess dressing instead of bleu cheese!

Anna F.Anna Frenkel: Chicken & palm salad over greens, hearts of palm, cucumber, tomato, shaved parmesan, and green goddess dressing.

Quantum Leap is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

12. Quantum Leap

7.9
1103 1st Ave (60/ 61 Sts), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 2 tips and reviews

Megan L.Megan Luff: Such good burgers! A huge range of choices. Brunch is also great here.

Alex @1LXAlex @1LX: All and all a great variety of vegan dishes delicious and fulfilling. With options of chicken and fish for you none vegan friends

Corner Cafe and Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

13. Corner Cafe and Bakery

7.2
1645 3rd Ave (btwn 92nd St and 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Café · Yorkville · 65 tips and reviews

Greg B.Greg Bodenair: Try the Honey Mustard Glazed Salmon - Entree course

Rebecca W.Rebecca W: Eat everything. It's all good. I highly recommend the scones. And the brownie pudding pie. And the cakes. Anything really.

Kim P.Kim P: farm cake muffins!!

Jasper's Taphouse & Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

14. Jasper's Taphouse & Kitchen

7.3
761 9th Ave (51st St.), New York, NY
Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 51 tips and reviews

Caroline W.Caroline Wu: Great service, had the wings and they were yummy - get them the honey mustard sauce!

Jacob C.Jacob Cass: The most amazing melt in your mouth chicken sliders. Do it.

Jacob C.Jacob Cass: From the same owners as Alfies! Awesome. Craft brew :)

Blondies Sports is one of The 15 Best Places for Honey Mustard in New York City.

15. Blondies Sports

7.5
212 W 79th St (btwn Broadway & Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Sports Bar · Upper West Side · 115 tips and reviews

Tariq A.Tariq Ahmad: Wings were overdone, but the chicken tenders are good. Honey mustard sauce was good.

Gary V.Gary V: Buffalo wings are good. Honey mustard wings are even better.

Cesar R.Cesar Razuri: Great neighborhood sports bar, with an even greater vibe. Aside from the amazing service, those chicken wings -- WOW -- you must get them if you visit.