Desmond: Try the Mushroom Slice - If you like mushrooms on your pizza this is the place to go! Fresh mushrooms, not the white ones you get from a can. Tastier difference!
N K: Tons of varieties of fresh pizzas. Personal favorite was fresh mushroom pizza and the creamy white pizza with garlic. My daughter loved the marinara pizza and wants to try the upside down pizza next
MAQ: Without a doubt, one of the best Pizza place in New York ( I've tried their Margarita, Chicken Buffalo & Fresh Mushroom and all were amazing 👌🏻)
2. Paolas Osteria
6.8
1246 Madison Ave (89th Street), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Carnegie Hill · 7 tips and reviews
Corinne Pulitzer: From the Caprese Salad to their many pastas & entrees, my fave is still their Margherita Pizza, add fresh mushrooms & baby artichokes for perfection!
Corinne Pulitzer: Love Osteria Paola! Authentic with all fresh ingredients & homemade pasta. Provided fresh and excellent meals throughout the pandemic and continue to bring excellent cuisine to the Upper East Side
Jason Schulweis: Great food, even better service, and a commitment to making sure your kids are treated impeccably. 10/10
7. Frank's Trattoria
7.8
371 1st Ave (btwn E 21st & E 22nd St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Gramercy Park · 18 tips and reviews
Vitor Coutinho @namesadopai: The Best veal parmegiana in NYC. Tip: ask about angel hair pasta with marinara souce.. Its perfect.
Sean Carroll: You can buy pizza here.
Wade V: High on flavor. Lots of garlic and spices in that sauce, loads of cheese. Best bet is an original cheese slice. Charming, because often the Italian owners are the ones serving you.
12. Pinocchio Ristorante
7.5
1748 1st Ave (at E 91st St.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Yorkville · 13 tips and reviews
Vani Prabakaran: truffle tortollini was aaaaamazing, and the veal tortollini was even better. Make sure you save room for dessert because the strawberry shortcake and homemade canoli were fantastic! Hidden gem!!
Anand Chopra-McGowan: Very small, very cozy, and very attentive staff!
New York Habitat: Great Italian food and a wonderful ambience! The staff is super attentive, quite rare for New York! Be sure to book a table in advance.
13. ABC Kitchen
9.2
35 E 18th St (btwn Broadway & Park Ave S), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 722 tips and reviews
Reserve: True to its commitment to locally sourced ingredients, ABC Kitchen delivers a farm-to-table whole wheat pizza topped with fresh mushrooms, Parmesan, oregano and a farm egg. Read more.
Laurent Raufaste: My favorite restaurant in NY, I'm a foodie and I love a lot of places in NY, but this one is as good as a starred Michelin, without the pricetag and the stars. To try it, book well in advance !
nymag: It’s not only the best place to catch the ‘vegetables are the new meat’ trend, it’s one of our favorite restaurants of the year. Featured in Where to Eat 2011! Read more.
Lauren: Best diner on the UES. Solid staples: eggs, home fries, wraps, etc. Great service & staff, too.
Ruben Brosbe: The York Ave is without a doubt the best item on a very solid menu
Anna Osgoodby: One of my favorite diners around the UES. The staff is great, the menu selection can't be beat and the food is delicious!