Levain Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

1. Levain Bakery

9.3
167 W 74th St (at Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 857 tips and reviews

Idan D.Idan Deutsch: I may not be a cookie connoisseur but these are hands down the best cookies I've ever had. The double chocolate peanut butter will change your life.

Kelsey✨Kelsey✨: The dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookie is SO GOOD. Full glass of milk required

Genesis G.Genesis Garcia: Absolutely delicious. Wish the chocolate chip didn't have walnuts. The dark chocolate peanut butter though is PERFECT.

Levain Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

2. Levain Bakery

9.1
2167 Frederick Douglass Blvd (117th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Central Harlem · 126 tips and reviews

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie - So rich

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie - Too good.

Sprinkles is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

3. Sprinkles

8.5
780 Lexington Avenue (btwn E 60th & E 61st St), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · Upper East Side · 199 tips and reviews

New York HabitatNew York Habitat: Everyone loves a good cupcake and Sprinkles just does it right. Get the Peanut Butter Chocolate cupcake for an experience your taste buds won't be ready for.

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Peanut Butter Chocolate Cupcake

SamiSami: Chocolate peanut butter is to die for. Make sure you come on a Wednesday or Saturday to try it

Insomnia Cookies is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

4. Insomnia Cookies

7.7
1579 2nd Ave (at E 82nd St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Yorkville · 46 tips and reviews

Rosemary R.Rosemary R.: #Cookieheaven! Warm cookies straight out of the oven. Chocolate Peanut Butter is to die for!!!

Brittney P.Brittney Potter: Love love love. Their cookies are served warm too. We had their chocolate peanut butter, peanut butter, s'more (my fav), and chocolate chip cookie all delicious! Also, they are opened late !

Christophe J.Christophe Jammet: They're on seamlessweb and they deliver. Best thing in the world when you're high.

Sundaes and Cones is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

5. Sundaes and Cones

8.9
95 E 10th St (btwn 3rd & 4th Ave), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · East Village · 293 tips and reviews

The Local East VillageThe Local East Village: Rachel Dratch of SNL fame calls this the best ice cream in the EV. "The chocolate peanut butter ice cream there will not fail you. I took one bite and I literally stopped in my tracks." Read more.

Jason G.Jason Gelman: Chocolate peanut butter

Olivier N.Olivier Nguyen Van Tan: Chocolate peanut butter is the way to go!

Oddfellows Ice Cream Co. is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

6. Oddfellows Ice Cream Co.

8.2
60 Water St, New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 12 tips and reviews

ShellyShelly: Vegan chocolate peanut butter vegan chocolate chunk is amazing!!

Kimmie O.Kimmie Ohh: In addition to their delectable ice cream flavors, they serve alcohol here! They have rosé boozy pops & summer spritz slushies. They also have beer & wine.

Lu H.Lu H: Love that they’ll split a scoop for you, so you can try two flavors without having to buy an enormous amount of ice cream!! Not many places will do this.

Sedutto is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

7. Sedutto

8.4
1498 1st Ave (btw 78th and 79th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Upper East Side · 45 tips and reviews

Go Find AliceGo Find Alice: Serves hard served yogurt??! Tastes like ice cream and delicious! Try the peanut butter chocolate chip flavor!

Steven B.Steven Brady: Milky way, butter praline, peanut butter crunch. Tr holy trinity

Jason L.Jason Lancaster: Peanut butter crunch. Tastes better than you thought possible.

The Grey Dog - Chelsea is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

8. The Grey Dog - Chelsea

8.7
242 W 16th St (btwn 7th & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Café · Chelsea · 386 tips and reviews

Billy B.Billy Boulia: The granola is fabulous as is the chocolate peanut butter cookie!!

Julie F.Julie F: Try the Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

Thea P.Thea Palad: Oh man, if I lived near this place I'd be so fucking fat. I cannot stop thinking about those giant chocolate peanut butter cookies. [drools on shirt]

Insomnia Cookies is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

9. Insomnia Cookies

8.2
482 3rd Ave (at 33rd St), New York, NY
Bakery · Rose Hill · 25 tips and reviews

Ida P.Ida Paras: Great for late night munchie because they're open till 2am. Really fun flavors, the peanut butter chocolate chip melts in your mouth.

Christina C.Christina Chin: So delish, big hit with kids and adults. Choc chunk is the way to go. 6 for $9, comes warm and gooey and in a box to carry out.

GayleGayle: The s'mores cookie is insanely good!!

Magnolia Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

10. Magnolia Bakery

8.8
1000 3rd Ave (Inside Bloomingdales), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper East Side · 138 tips and reviews

Diana G.Diana Garcia: Lemon pie and peanut butter chocolate pie. Deliciosooooo

Rock RainesRock Raines: Chocolate peanut butter bar was inhaled

J P.J P: My top picks are the caramel cupcakes and the banana pudding.

Bareburger is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

11. Bareburger

8.2
535 Laguardia Pl (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Greenwich Village · 193 tips and reviews

Pacey B.Pacey Barron: Get the peanut butter chocolate shake! Delicious.

Amy H.Amy Hyde: Peanut Butter Chocolate Shake... DELISH!!

Jeanne C.Jeanne Cho: Get the chocolate peanut butter shake. Dogs on patio!👍🎉

Billy's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

12. Billy's Bakery

8.1
184 9th Ave (btw 21st & 22nd St), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · Chelsea · 209 tips and reviews

Alisa V.Alisa Vogel: The peanut butter chocolate bar is absolutely to die for!!!

Chad H.Chad Horner: Peanut Butter Chocolate bar. It's exactly what it sounds like, and it's wonderful.

Winson W.Winson Wong: The banana cake and pudding is delicious. Overall their cakes are really good. There are seats inside the bakery as well which is good to hang out. There are also two benches outside for the summer.

Blossom Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

13. Blossom Bakery

7.8
174 9th Ave (21st Street), New York, NY
Bakery · Chelsea · 13 tips and reviews

Zahid Z.Zahid Zaman: A vegan peanut butter chocolate chip cookie? Yespls!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: An assortment of vegan cupcakes. Expect to find flavors like red velvet, pumpkin, and black-bottom cupcakes in addition to traditional favorites such as chocolate and vanilla.

Ethan t.Ethan the Vegan: Seriously, THE. BEST. BAKERY. EVER! Vegan or not, why go anywhere else??

Molly's Cupcakes is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

14. Molly's Cupcakes

8.9
228 Bleecker St (at Carmine St), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · West Village · 254 tips and reviews

MandiMandi: This place is delicious!! Cupcakes taste homemade...lots of great flavors (try the chocolate peanut butter). Good coffee too!!

Cynthia L.Cynthia Lin: Great flavors. Usually a chocolate peanut butter desserter but the apple cupcake was just too good

Brandie W.Brandie Webb: Amazing cupcakes in NYC. Pick a cupcake and add any amount of frosting. I add just a little.

The Grey Dog - Union Square is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in New York City.

15. The Grey Dog - Union Square

8.5
90 University Pl (btwn E 11th & E 12th St), New York, NY
Café · Greenwich Village · 327 tips and reviews

David S.David Schorr: Chocolate peanut butter chip cookies!!

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie - Massive. And really good too.

Gaia B.Gaia Bennett: Great menu and great vibe. Unlimited refills on coffee! They have a great selection of sandwiches and salad, too. The ideal place to meet a friend for breakfast during the week. You are lovely, GD!