Presbyterian Deli 2 is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

1. Presbyterian Deli 2

7.6
2119 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
Deli · Washington Heights · 4 tips and reviews

Carrie S.Carrie Shumway: Awesome BBQ chicken sandwiches! Free soda with your sandwich.

Romulus M.Romulus Murrell: The Cuban sandwich is good

Christine H.Christine Humes: Love the turkey deli sandwich xoxo

Lucky's Famous Burgers is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

2. Lucky's Famous Burgers

7.1
370 W 52nd St (at 9th Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Hell's Kitchen · 89 tips and reviews

Corey K.Corey Kelly: This burger joint's menu is unfortunately pretty overpriced. Burgers are greasy which score a 3 out of 5 on my scale. Aim for the standouts: The juicy BBQ chicken sandwich and yumm-ified cheese fries!

TomTom: Great made-to-order burgers and fries. Lucky sauce makes everything better!

Kevin M.Kevin Myers: Best damn burgers in town! Happily located in a gay area for gays who don't give a rat's ass about carbs, fat or calories. Order anything, but the chili cheese fries are tops!

Peter McManus is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

3. Peter McManus

7.5
152 7th Ave (at W 19th St), New York, NY
Bar · Chelsea · 75 tips and reviews

Danny P.Danny Polise: BBQ chicken sandwich or turkey club are the way to go. Great bartenders!

Amy T.Amy Tremmel: Awesome classic Irish pub. Good mix of people here and really friendly bartenders. Great selection of beers on tap and a good price!

Matt G.Matt G: Unpretentious pub with great food. Pat the bartender is a gem. Patrons are really friendly. Nice ambiance. Read more.

Houston Village Farm is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

4. Houston Village Farm

7.0
61 1st Ave (at 4th St), New York, NY
Deli · East Village · 6 tips and reviews

prakash s.prakash sheth: This places makes sandwiches just like the ones your Mom used to pack you for lunch. If you don't know what I mean, try it out. Really great, fresh delicatessen that has a wide variety of options an

AdrienAdrien: Breakfast sandwiches to start your day right. Turkey / Egg & Cheese never wrong

Andrew F.Andrew Furman: Great drink selection. Beers and non beers

Prohibition is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

5. Prohibition

7.8
503 Columbus Ave (btwn 84th & 85th St.), New York, NY
Bar · Upper West Side · 81 tips and reviews

Jody G.Jody Gnant: Never had a menu item I didn't like. Order the mojito with light sugar. Quinn, the GM, is fantastic. :)

FrankieFrankie: Check out Sean and Jeff on Tuesdays!

Reign L.Reign Low: Steak nacho's are so good with a glass of Stella... Live bands are really good I'll be back soon

The Dead Poet is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

6. The Dead Poet

7.0
450 Amsterdam Ave (btwn 81st & 82nd St), New York, NY
Pub · Upper West Side · 92 tips and reviews

DJ M.DJ Moore: Great atmosphere and free popcorn. Also free wifi. Just as for the password.

Nicole H.Nicole Hering: wifi password is 'jameson1'

Fernando d.Fernando de Leon: To Arthur!!!

GMT Tavern is one of The 7 Best Places for BBQ Chicken Sandwich in New York City.

7. GMT Tavern

7.6
142 Bleecker St (btwn Thompson St & Laguardia Pl), New York, NY
Gastropub · Greenwich Village · 81 tips and reviews

Meg M.Meg McNamara: Cobb salad is very tasty. Outdoor seating is wonderful too.

Kelli J.Kelli Johnson: Try the fries!!! They are deelish.

Scott K.Scott Kerr: Want to get away from the NYU crowd while still being in their "hood" stop by here.