1. Hillstone
9.0
378 Park Ave S (at E 27th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · NoMad · 265 tips and reviews
Marie Desdunes: Burgers are awesome. I had veggie burger and cheese burger. Worth the $15 it cost. substitute the fries it comes with for a loaded baked potatoe, its so much better. The fries they have are shoestring
Kid Eats: Get the Spinnach and Artichoke Dip. Hillstone Burger with Baked Potato
John Torres: The BBQ Pork Ribs with the loaded baked potato plate is a must try before you die!!! Wash it down with a margarita on the rocks! Insanely delicious. Save room for the five nut brownie for dessert.
2. Cowgirl
7.7
519 Hudson St (at W 10th St), New York, NY
Tex-Mex Restaurant · West Village · 159 tips and reviews
Jase: Order the baked potato for DESSERT! #win
Georgina O.: The hangar steak followed by the ice cream baked potato is one of my favorite meals in the world.
Rachel Altvater: Margaritas, specials, pulled pork, salads, baked potato sundae
5. Sparks Steak House
7.8
210 E 46th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Turtle Bay · 83 tips and reviews
The Corcoran Group: Take in the old school atmosphere and get ready for one of the best Sirloin Steaks around. Add a baked potato and a vegetable. But save room for desert and get the Ice Cream Tartufo.
BECKIE 💋🐶🌻💜💫 PODLECKIS: Steak and baked potato, enough to feed 3! Famous historical landmark for #OldGanstaMob, still #GoodOleBoyClub
HISTORY: In a hit orchestrated by John Gotti, Gambino family crime lord Paul Castellano and his henchman, Thomas Bilotti, were gunned down as they exited this restaurant December 16, 1985.
6. American Cut
8.2
363 Greenwich St (btw Harrison & Franklin), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Tribeca · 96 tips and reviews
Mark Gracia: Get the rib eye, very unique preparation with the pastrami and mustard run, also get the twice baked potatoes for a truffle treat.
Lee Simpson: Best steakhouse in Manhattan. The twice baked potatoes are insane.
Julie Soscia: Great steak and NYC ambiance. Don't be surprised to spot some celebs in this neighborhood. Solid Restaurant Week option as well - and don't forget to try the biscuits.
7. 4 Charles Prime Rib
9.3
4 Charles St (Greenwich Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · West Village · 67 tips and reviews
Lori Sherman: The burger fully loaded is amazing! The prime rib is perfect! Great corn, Brussel sprouts & baked potatoes. Loved the lemon meringue & chocolate pie for dessert. Can’t wait to go back!
AlAnoud A AlGhunaim: This place lives up to its reputation, one of the best steaks you’ll ever try hands down! Lively ambiance, very classy. Dry aged ribeye steak, carbonara pasta, American cheeseburger & creamed spinach✨
Julie Winkelman: Must get the French dip!
8. Strip House
8.8
15 W 44th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 57 tips and reviews
Emily Bennett: The porterhouse is delicious, but the sides are DIVINE. The creamed corn is my favorite, and the baked potato mash is amazing. Waiter described as "Irish mac'n cheese". Choc cake is excellent & huge!
Sarah Medina: It’s pricey but worth it. One of the more st memorable meals. The steak was cooked perfectly and the potatoes were garlicky and addicting. Topped off with the layer cake. Yummmmm
Geoffroy Bablon: The porterhouse for two is one big, tasty steak. Just charred on the outside, super tender on the inside. Get it with a bottle of Belle Pente Pinot noir.
9. BLT Steak
8.6
106 E 57th St (at Park Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 97 tips and reviews
Emily Cramer: Food was great! Crab cake=all crab, porterhouse steak=cooked perfectly, huge baked potato, and the honey bacon Brussel sprouts were amazing. Plus the bread came with a recipe, can't wait to try it!
M W: Yes, the popovers are amazing. Otherwise, erratic service & the room is LOUD. Fresh fish, GREAT short ribs & solid wine list. Not the best steak in the city but good choice for meetings & occasions!
Michelle Mu: save a little space for dessert and you will be amazed.
10. Bus Stop Cafe
7.9
597 Hudson St (Bethune St), New York, NY
Diner · West Village · 51 tips and reviews
Tom H: Dinner Salmon with asparagus and baked sweet potato, delicious.
Susan J Campbell: Outdoor tables are lovely, staff is friendly, food is good. Watermelon salad was great. Gazpacho very good.
Nick Bhutani: Love the veggie burger!
11. Bowery Meat Company
8.5
9 E 1st St (btwn 2nd Ave & Bowery), New York, NY
Steakhouse · East Village · 98 tips and reviews
Missy Mackey: Great service with a stunning presentation of steaks, everything was delicious. Got the porterhouse, whipped ricotta appetizer, shishito peppers, loaded baked potato and carrot cake (10/10)
Steven Rosenblatt: Duck Lasagna and Broiled Oysters are a must w/ any steak. Chef Capon always brings the best.
Thrillist: Go for the the broiled oysters (w/ garlic, breadcrumbs, and Romano), stay for the duck lasagna. Read more.
John K: Tuna Tartare was very good w/avocado,cucumber, tomato & toast. Bone in ribeye with a baked potato makes for a happy diner tonight! Best steak I've had in quite some time! Worth the walk and the money!
Kenny Imafidon: The Canadian bacon and porter house were both amazing!!!
Albert Sun: Look for Marc in the back corner.
13. Smith & Wollensky
8.5
797 3rd Ave (at E 49th St), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Turtle Bay · 236 tips and reviews
Jinnie L: Their cajun ribeye was pretty tasty & huge. loaded baked potato was my favorite part ;)
Daniel Karran: Another one of Manhattan's fine steakhouses. Atmosphere, food, wine, service are all impeccable! A must go if you're visiting NYC! After all, this place was included in The Devil Wears Prada! ;)
Food Network: Anne Burrell craves the Coconut Layer Cake dessert at Smith & Wollensky on Food Network's The Best Thing I Ever Ate. Find more tips at Food Network Local. Read more.
14. Molly's Shebeen
7.8
287 3rd Ave (btwn E 22nd & 23rd St.), New York, NY
Irish Pub · Gramercy Park · 128 tips and reviews
Nancy Kang: U can't go wrong w/ the corned beef & cabbage here. The meat is the leanest corned beef I've seen. Comes w/ plenty of meat & cabbage w/ some carrots too, a peeled baked potato & a yummy dill sauce.
Robert Fiore: Awesome burger on a pretzel roll. Sheppard’s Pie, Chicken Pot Pie with a pastry crust. Ruben sandwich. Fish and chips (fresh cod). All soo good!
The New York Times: There are days when the only proper response to life is bangers and mash, pints of Guinness and sawdust on the floor. Here’s your man.
15. Chirping Chicken
6.9
355 Amsterdam Ave (at W 77th St), New York, NY
Comfort Food Restaurant · Upper West Side · 85 tips and reviews
Amanda Williams: Arroz con pollo is a family favorite but chicken and fries always also a big hit with the kids. Nice baked sweet potato and rice pudding.
BuzzFeed: This place doesn’t overcook the chicken, gives you a choice between salad and mac and cheese, and serves baked potatoes and sweet potatoes that are soft and hot and wonderfully plain. Read more.
Ben R: Rotisserie chicken with fresh tomato sauce (it's not marinara). So good.