2. Luke's Lobster
8.8
242 E 81st St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Yorkville · 141 tips and reviews
Rosa An: The Taste of Maine is a great way to taste the lobster, shrimp, and crab rolls. Grab a tasty blueberry soda and the salt and vinegar chips. The lobster bisque is delicious and chock full of lobster
Noelle: love the taste of Maine, lobster, shrimp and crab roll, all so fresh!
Sondra C: Lobster roll and bread bowl are amazing
3. Burger & Lobster
8.4
39 W 19th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Flatiron District · 287 tips and reviews
Danielle Sang: I went to the one in London and loved the burger. I tried the steamed Lobster and it was delicious! Great value for the price. Lobster rolls aren't my thing but they are very good here.
Nandi Anderson: Burger, Lobster, or Lobster Roll. And a salad and fries. The food comes out QUICK! And it's delicious!
Oleksii Panteleichuk: Excellent lobsters (ans sizes!), excellent burgers! Highly Recommended!
4. Luke's Lobster
8.9
26 S William St (btwn Beaver St & Mill Ln), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Financial District · 144 tips and reviews
Alex Rivera: Amazing lobster rolls! Amazing everything rolls to be honest! & now they serve beer! Try the Allagash beer its so good!
Elaine Kwan: Can't go wrong with the lobster roll as a first timer. Won't disappoint. Go for the combo. The soda is delish!
Erica Virtue: Great lobster roll. Love that it's served with butter and seasoning, rather than in a mayonnaise-based sauce!
6. Mary's Fish Camp
8.4
64 Charles St (at W 4th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · West Village · 140 tips and reviews
Dominic Preuss: HarryH is right, best lobster roll in the city but the star is the whole grilled daily fish. I prefer the bronzini!
Dominic Preuss: Best lobster roll in NYC. Whole bronzini is the 2nd best dish. Sundae's are amazing too.
Bobby Dacron: Lobster roll, bouillabaisse , mahi mahi , skate ribs ....actually the whole feckin menu
7. Cull & Pistol
8.7
75 9th Ave, New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Chelsea · 141 tips and reviews
Clara Ximena Montealegre: This is tops on my list of best restaurants un NYC The lobster were incredible, amazing sample of raw oysters, and moussels was perfect.
Austin Auh: The service is amazing (great wine recommendations) and you have to get the lobster.
Dmitriy Fedorov: Great place to get some fresh seafood. Lobster and oysters are the best
8. Mermaid Oyster Bar
8.9
79 Macdougal St (btwn Bleecker & W Houston St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 269 tips and reviews
Stephen Merrill: Lobster roll and lobster fra diavolo simple and tasty. Great space for summer evenings, and terrific, friendly service.
Vincent Crossley: Awesome (and large) lobster roll, great staff!
Chad Rodriguez: Try the lobster roll - Great texture, very #fresh with a bit of #spice
9. Marea
9.3
240 Central Park S (at 59th St & Broadway), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Theater District · 356 tips and reviews
Caroline Schulweis: Get the ricci and astice to start (uni and lobster w/ burrata). The strozzapreti and the fusilli were both amazing pastas!
Halalfoodcritic: Excellent sirloin steak, lobster antipasti dish, and doughnuts
Tiago Sardeli: Everything! Soft shell crab, lobster burata is a must!!! Pasta is fantastic
10. Beauty & Essex
8.8
146 Essex St (btwn Stanton & Rivington St), New York, NY
Tapas Restaurant · Lower East Side · 579 tips and reviews
Dmitriy S: Great place with an awesome crowd. Must get the lobster tacos, chicken meatballs, and the ricotta with appricots.
Elizabeth Pace: For brunch, get lobster tacos and fried chicken biscuits! Delish and so filling!
Johnny Sibilly: -Grilled Cheese, Bacon & Tomato Soup Dumplings-Chicken Fried Oysters -Lobster TacosGet them all or you don't love yourself! Amazing Amazing Amazing
11. Catch
8.4
21 9th Ave (at W 13th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Meatpacking District · 328 tips and reviews
Giulio del Bufalo: Mini lobster rolls, crispy shrimp, catch of the day, but above all... smores pizza!
Jane Cho: Food is amazing...try the Catch roll, tuna tartare rice cakes and lobster mac&cheese...yum!
The Commander: Great cocktails, tartare trio, truffle sashimi, lobster Mac and cheese!!!
14. Buddakan
9.0
75 9th Ave (at W 16th St), New York, NY
Chinese Restaurant · Chelsea · 526 tips and reviews
Omkar Karnik: Rockin shrimp is mouth watering. Edamame dumplings are really good. Lobster fried rice is a must. And to sum it up, Crying Chocolate was one of the best desserts that I have ever had!!
Debbie Lee: The shrimp and lobster chow fun is AMAZING, as is the filet of beef - the flavors are full of depth! Finish your meal with crying chocolate and almond bread pudding! Wow! :)
Michael Fox-Rabinovitz: Peking duck, lobster rolls, great cocktails... Pretty much can't go wrong here. Loved the space as well, the candles add a great ambiance.
15. Ai Fiori
8.7
400 5th Ave Ph 2 (at W 36th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Garment District · 176 tips and reviews
Connie K: Get the... blue crab avocado, Risotto and Butter poached lobster :)
Saneel Radia: Try the Butter-Poached Nova Scotia Lobster - Perfectly cooked lobster, and don't worry, the decadent butter doesn't over power the freshness of the dish
Veronica H: Pleasantly surprised! Agnolotti veal parcels are a must get and the poached lobster. Get the fluke crudo-it's smothered in caviar and sits in a pool of Mayer lemon and cream